The School Gym Floor and the AHERA Three-Year Re-inspection
You are the accredited inspector conducting a three-year AHERA re-inspection at a K-12 school. The prior inspection (six years ago) identified 9-inch vinyl floor tile with black mastic in the gym as ACM. The school replaced the gym floor two years ago with new tile over the old, without abatement. The maintenance log shows a pipe fitting repair in 2019 where insulation was disturbed and re-wrapped. The school also has a boiler room with TSI that was sampled and found non-ACM. The principal asks whether the school can skip the re-inspection this cycle because 'nothing has changed.' The AHERA management plan is in the office but the last periodic surveillance entry is 14 months old.
1. Can the school skip the re-inspection? What are the compliance issues?
Read the worked answer
No. AHERA requires re-inspection at least once every three years for each school building with ACM, and periodic surveillance every six months. The 14-month gap in surveillance is a deficiency the school must correct. Skipping the re-inspection would be noncompliant.
The 'nothing has changed' claim is also false: the gym floor was covered with new tile over ACM, which is a change in condition/accessibility that must be documented. Covering ACM does not remove it and does not eliminate the re-inspection obligation. The 2019 pipe repair is another event that should be reflected in the management plan and surveillance records.
I would complete the re-inspection, document the covered floor as ACM (with the covering noted), and flag the surveillance gap in writing to the principal and the designated person.
2. How do you treat the gym floor and the boiler room TSI in your re-inspection?
Read the worked answer
Gym floor: the original 9-inch tile and mastic are still present beneath the new tile. I would not re-sample through the new floor. I would document the ACM as present but covered, note the covering date if known, and assess condition as intact/covered. The management plan must reflect that the material is still ACM and that any future disturbance of the covering requires care. I would visually assess the new floor for damage that could expose the old material.
Boiler room TSI: it was sampled and found non-ACM previously. I would confirm the prior report and sample locations. If the material is unchanged and the prior sampling was adequate (representative, documented), I can rely on it and note it as previously determined non-ACM. However, if the 2019 repair introduced new insulation or if the prior sampling was a single sample of a large, varied system, I would consider additional sampling. I would not assume non-ACM for all TSI based on one sample.
3. What must the re-inspection report and management plan update include?
Read the worked answer
The re-inspection report should document: date, inspector accreditation, each homogeneous area and material, current condition (intact, damaged, significantly damaged), accessibility, and any changes since the last inspection. It should note the covered gym floor, the 2019 repair, and the surveillance gap.
The management plan update should include: updated condition assessments, a corrected surveillance schedule, a plan for the covered floor, and a response action plan for any damaged material. I would also recommend the school resume six-month surveillance immediately and document the reason for the gap. I would provide written findings to the designated person and keep copies in my records.