The Strategic Plan That Nobody Owns
A nonprofit with a $5M budget and 40 staff adopted a 3-year strategic plan 18 months ago. The plan has 5 goals and 22 objectives. A recent board survey shows that only 30% of board members feel the plan is relevant, and staff report that the plan sits on a shelf. The ED is focused on daily operations and has not scheduled a single progress review. Two of the five goals were based on assumptions about a major grant that was not renewed. The board chair wants to 'refresh' the plan by hiring a consultant for $25K. The finance committee notes that the budget has no line for strategic initiatives. The development director says that funders are asking for outcomes data that the organization cannot provide.
1. What are the root causes of the plan's failure, and what should the ED recommend to the board?
Read the worked answer
Root causes: (1) Lack of ownership-no regular progress reviews or assigned accountability; (2) Unrealistic assumptions-goals tied to a grant that was not renewed; (3) No resource allocation-budget lacks funding for strategic initiatives; (4) Poor communication-board and staff disconnected from the plan; (5) No measurement system-unable to report outcomes to funders.
Recommendation: Do not hire a consultant for a full refresh yet. Instead, conduct an internal assessment: (a) review each goal against current reality and identify which are still viable; (b) assign a staff lead and board liaison for each remaining goal; (c) integrate the plan into the annual budget cycle by creating a strategic initiative line item; (d) establish quarterly progress reviews with a simple dashboard of 3-5 key indicators per goal; (e) revise or retire goals that are no longer feasible. Only after this internal work should the board consider a consultant to facilitate a broader refresh. The ED should present this plan at the next board meeting.
2. How should the ED address the funders' request for outcomes data?
Read the worked answer
The ED should acknowledge that the organization lacks a coherent outcomes measurement system and propose a short-term and long-term solution. Short-term: identify data already being collected (e.g., program attendance, client satisfaction) and compile a report for funders within 30 days, being transparent about limitations. Long-term: incorporate outcome measurement into the strategic plan refresh, with a budget for data systems and staff training. The ED should also engage program staff to define realistic outcomes and indicators. Funders value honesty and a credible improvement plan over inflated claims.