The Wallet That Belongs to Somebody Else
A decomposed body is found in a drainage culvert beside a county road. The wallet in the trouser pocket holds a driver's license for "R.T.," age 41, listing a height of 183 cm, plus two $50 bills and a pawn ticket dated nine days earlier. The right hand is absent below the wrist; the left hand is mummified. A tattoo on the left forearm reads "MOM 1987." The decedent measures 178 cm. A woman calls saying her brother R.T. has been missing ten days and describes a scar on his knee. A second caller, R.T.'s roommate, says R.T. lent his wallet to a friend three weeks ago and never got it back. No dental records have been located yet.
1. Lay out an identification strategy and explain what each method can and cannot establish.
Read the worked answer
Do not release the name on the strength of the wallet. The wallet is property found with the body, not identification of the body - and the roommate's account weakens its evidentiary value further.
Rank the methods:
- Fingerprints - the mummified left hand may be rehydrated and printed by a latent-print examiner. If a print is obtained and matches a known record, that is conclusive and fast. The missing right hand removes half the opportunity.
- Dental - the most reliable route for a skeletonized/putrefied decedent, and it needs a comparator. Ask the sister for the name of R.T.'s dentist; many people don't know, so pursue it through the family's insurance or the missing-person report. Take full dental radiographs and charting now, even before a comparator exists.
- DNA - the slow but definitive backstop. Collect a bone or tooth sample at autopsy and a reference sample from a sibling or parent. Expect weeks to months.
- Presumptive only: height (178 vs. a listed 183 cm is a discrepancy that needs explaining, not ignoring - shoes, posture, and license error all matter), tattoo, and the sister's scar description.
Enter the case into the appropriate missing/unidentified persons database and cross-match the missing-person report early.
2. What do you do with the property, the cash, and the pawn ticket?
Read the worked answer
Inventory before anything leaves the body. Photograph the wallet in situ if possible; then open it, list every item, count and record the denominations and serial numbers or at least the denominations (§100 total), and photograph the contents laid out with a scale and case number.
Chain of custody from the first touch. Every transfer gets a name, date, and time. Cash goes into a sealed, initialed evidence envelope; do not "hold" it in a pocket or a desk drawer.
Do not release property to the sister yet. She has not been established as the next of kin of this decedent - she may be the sister of a living R.T. whose wallet was lent to someone else. Property release follows positive identification and authority to receive the remains.
The pawn ticket is a lead, not clutter. It carries a date nine days before discovery, a shop name, and possibly a name or description of the person who pawned the item. Photograph it, log the shop and date, and pass the lead to the investigator. It may place a person other than R.T. in possession of R.T.'s wallet close in time to the death.
Document all of it in the property report - courts and families both read those records later.
3. The sister calls twice a day asking for confirmation. How do you handle communication while identification is pending?
Read the worked answer
Be honest about the state of the evidence without speculating.
- Tell her what you can: a decedent has been found, description and property are being examined, and identification is not yet confirmed.
- Do not confirm the identity informally to end the conversation. If it later turns out to be the friend who borrowed the wallet, an informal confirmation to R.T.'s sister has caused a family to grieve a living man and has contaminated a potential investigation.
- Give her a concrete next step and a time frame: what you need from her (dentist's name, medical records, a DNA reference sample from a sibling), and when she will hear from you next.
- Use the scar description as a checklist item in the examination, not as confirmation.
Ask about the friend who borrowed the wallet - name, description, last contact - and pass that to the investigator alongside the pawn lead. The sister's calls are also a source of investigative information if you listen for it.