Release of Records in a Custody Dispute
Dr. L is a rehabilitation psychologist who treated Ms. A for 14 months after a spinal cord injury, addressing adjustment, depression, and return-to-work planning. Ms. A is now in a contested custody dispute with her ex-husband. His attorney subpoenas Dr. L's complete record, including psychotherapy notes, and asks for a deposition. Ms. A has not signed a release. The subpoena is signed by a court clerk but is not accompanied by a court order. Dr. L's records include sensitive details about Ms. A's sexual functioning and her statements about her ex-husband.
1. What is your response to the subpoena?
Read the worked answer
A subpoena is not a court order and does not by itself authorize release of protected health information. Do not release the full record on receipt.
Steps: (1) Verify the subpoena's validity and scope; (2) notify the patient (Ms. A) promptly so she can object or seek to quash; (3) assert privilege on her behalf unless she waives it; (4) release only what is legally required, and only after a court order or valid authorization, or after the patient's objection is resolved.
Distinguish psychotherapy notes from the rest of the record - they have heightened protection and should not be produced absent a specific court order. Do not treat the clerk's signature as judicial authorization. Document every step and consult your malpractice carrier or an attorney if the subpoena is pressed.
2. The attorney asks for your opinion on Ms. A's fitness as a parent. How do you respond?
Read the worked answer
Decline to offer a custody or parenting-capacity opinion. You treated her for adjustment and return-to-work; you did not conduct a forensic parenting evaluation, did not assess the child, and did not use forensic methods. Offering an opinion would exceed your role and could harm both the patient and the legal process.
You may testify, if properly ordered, to factual clinical observations within your treatment role - e.g., her engagement, her functioning at the time of treatment - while being explicit about the limits of those observations and that they were not gathered for forensic purposes.
Clarify your role in writing to the attorney: treating clinician, not expert evaluator. If a parenting evaluation is needed, recommend an independent forensic evaluator. This protects the patient, the record, and your objectivity.
3. Ms. A asks you to 'just send everything, I have nothing to hide.' What do you do?
Read the worked answer
Honor her autonomy but slow the process so the waiver is informed. Explain what the record contains (sexual functioning, statements about her ex-husband), who will see it, and that it may be used in the dispute. Confirm the authorization is specific, written, and voluntary, and that she understands she can withdraw it before release.
Consider a limited release (relevant portions only) if that meets the legal need, and confirm with her attorney whether a narrower production is possible. Do not override her decision, but do not let a casual 'send everything' substitute for informed consent.
Document the conversation, her authorization, and the scope released. If her attorney advises against release, defer to that and let the court resolve any conflict.