The Unsigned Critical Requisition
A depot memo issued on 24 February reads: 'From 1 March, requisitions marked CRITICAL must be countersigned by a duty manager before dispatch. Unsigned critical requisitions are held, not rejected, and processed on the next business day. The CRITICAL category is reserved for items whose absence halts an operational task; delays caused by misclassification are reported to the section head.' On Friday 7 March at 16:40, Priya lodges an unsigned CRITICAL requisition for 40 marker flags needed for a Monday 08:00 training exercise. The flags are already in stock. Duty managers work Monday to Friday, 08:00-17:00 only. The depot processes no requisitions over the weekend and has no weekend duty roster.
1. Three conclusions are offered: (a) the requisition will be rejected; (b) the flags will be at the exercise by 08:00 Monday; (c) the requisition is held pending a countersignature. Which is best supported, and why do the other two fail?
Read the worked answer
Best supported: (c).
- The memo states unsigned critical requisitions are held, not rejected, so (a) contradicts the text directly.
- The requisition is lodged at 16:40 Friday with no countersignature. Nothing is processed over the weekend, and a duty manager is first available 08:00 Monday, so the earliest possible dispatch is Monday, after the exercise has begun. (b) requires an event the memo does not permit.
- (c) is the only option that follows from the stated rule without adding facts.
Note the distinction being tested: held and rejected are different outcomes, and 'needed Monday' is a requirement, not an entitlement.
2. Does a scheduled training exercise fit the memo's definition of CRITICAL? What exposure does Priya carry, and what should she have done differently on Friday?
Read the worked answer
The definition is 'items whose absence halts an operational task'. A training exercise is a scheduled activity that can usually be postponed, substituted (chalk, cones, tape) or run short-handed, so absence is unlikely to halt an operational task. On the plain wording, the classification is doubtful.
Exposure: the memo routes delays caused by misclassification to the section head, so Priya risks a report rather than a simple rejection.
Better course on Friday: either obtain the countersignature before 17:00 (the only window that preserves Monday delivery), or submit as routine with an explicit required-by date and follow up by phone. Submitting late on a Friday as CRITICAL maximises both the delay and the misclassification risk.
3. What single additional fact would most change your answer to the first task?
Read the worked answer
Whether a duty manager was contactable or had pre-authorised out-of-hours countersignature. If a manager had already signed, or could sign electronically on Saturday, the hold never binds and the flags could move Monday morning.
Secondary candidates that would matter less: whether the depot has a Friday late-dispatch cut-off (it affects timing but not the countersignature rule), and whether 'next business day' was ever defined to include Saturday operations. The governing constraint is the signature, so evidence about the signature is the highest-value fact.