The adolescent who asks you not to tell her parents
A 16-year-old girl attends alone and asks that her visit remain confidential. She discloses that she has been sexually active with a 19-year-old boyfriend for 3 months, uses condoms 'most of the time,' and has had 2 weeks of vaginal discharge with mild lower abdominal discomfort. She is tearful and says her parents 'would kill her' if they knew. She is not sure whether she wants testing for pregnancy or STIs and asks you not to tell anyone. Your jurisdiction allows minors to consent to confidential sexual health care, but you are unsure of the exact local age threshold.
1. How do you handle confidentiality, and what is the ethical framework?
Read the worked answer
Start by explaining the limits of confidentiality before she discloses further: what will be kept private, and the specific circumstances in which you would need to involve others (risk of serious harm, safeguarding concerns, statutory reporting). This respects her autonomy and builds trust.
The ethical framework is assent/consent capacity plus best interests: many jurisdictions allow minors to consent to confidential sexual health care, and where the law is uncertain you should verify the local threshold rather than guess. Her capacity to understand the implications of testing and treatment should be assessed. Confidentiality is not absolute but should be breached only to the minimum extent necessary and with her knowledge where possible.
2. She is 16 and her partner is 19. Does this change anything, and how do you explore safety?
Read the worked answer
Age of consent and close-in-age provisions vary by jurisdiction, so the key step is to check the local legal position and follow safeguarding policy rather than assume. Regardless of legal reporting thresholds, you should screen for coercion, exploitation, and intimate partner violence - a 3-year age gap at 16 is not automatically abusive, but you must ask.
Use a non-judgemental, direct approach: ask whether she feels safe, whether she can say no, whether the relationship is consensual, and whether there is pressure around condom use. If there are safeguarding concerns, follow the local child protection pathway and explain to her what you are doing and why. Document the assessment.
3. What clinical care do you offer, and how do you balance her request with parental involvement?
Read the worked answer
Offer a full confidential sexual health assessment: pregnancy test, NAAT for chlamydia and gonorrhoea (self-taken or clinician-taken), syphilis and HIV testing with consent, and consider pelvic inflammatory disease given discharge and lower abdominal pain. Treat empirically per local guidance if PID is suspected and arrange follow-up.
Discuss contraception - she is using condoms inconsistently, so offer long-acting reversible contraception and emergency contraception information. Encourage, but do not coerce, parental involvement: explain that a trusted adult can help, and explore whether there is another safe adult. Respect her decision if she declines, provided there are no safeguarding concerns requiring escalation. Give written sexual health information and a clear follow-up plan.