The Patient Who Refuses His Antipsychotic
A 34-year-old man with a diagnosis of schizophrenia is admitted to an acute inpatient mental health unit after his family reported he had stopped his medication 3 weeks ago. He is pacing, speaking rapidly about 'the transmitter in the wall', and has not slept for two nights. He is not physically aggressive. He tells the nurse, 'I'm not taking that poison. You're all in on it.' He has capacity to understand the information about treatment. The team wants to restart his regular oral antipsychotic. He refuses. The nurse is asked by the registrar to 'just give it covertly in his tea - he won't know'.
1. What are the legal and ethical issues in giving the medication covertly, and what should the nurse do?
Read the worked answer
Covert administration is not acceptable here. Giving medication disguised in food or drink without the patient's knowledge:
- Violates the principle of informed consent and the patient's right to refuse treatment.
- Is not permitted under DOH regulations or UAE law for a patient who has capacity. Covert administration may only be considered in exceptional circumstances, under a formal legal framework, with multidisciplinary and family involvement, and where the patient lacks capacity - none of which is established here.
- The nurse has a professional duty to advocate for the patient and to refuse an instruction that is unlawful or unsafe. 'The doctor told me to' is not a defence.
What the nurse should do:
- Decline clearly and professionally: 'I can't give medication without his knowledge - that would be covert administration and it isn't lawful or within our policy.'
- Ask for a proper assessment - has capacity been formally assessed and documented? Is there a legal framework for treatment without consent in this jurisdiction? The registrar should be asked to document the rationale.
- Offer alternatives within the law: continue to engage the patient, offer oral medication again later, explore his concerns, involve the family with his consent, and if he becomes a risk to himself or others, follow the emergency provisions and the least restrictive option.
- Escalate to the nurse in charge and the consultant psychiatrist, and document the request, the refusal, and the actions taken.
- Report if the instruction is repeated - this is a patient safety and professional conduct issue.
The examiner wants the nurse to know that advocacy and lawful practice override a doctor's instruction, and that the response must be calm, documented, and escalated.
2. The patient later becomes agitated and attempts to leave the unit. What is the nurse's priority and what principles guide any restrictive intervention?
Read the worked answer
Priority: keep the patient and others safe, using the least restrictive option, and assess risk first.
- Engage and de-escalate: calm voice, give space, offer choices, acknowledge his distress, and involve people he trusts. Most agitation resolves with good communication.
- Assess risk: is he a risk to himself (traffic, self-harm), to others, or is he unable to care for himself? Document the assessment.
- Prevent him leaving if he lacks capacity and is at risk - but only within the legal framework. In many jurisdictions this means the nurse informs the nurse in charge and the psychiatrist immediately and follows the unit's policy; physical restraint is a last resort.
- If restraint or rapid tranquillisation is needed: it must be authorised, the least restrictive, time-limited, monitored (vital signs, circulation, respiration), documented, and the patient reviewed afterwards. Never as punishment or for staff convenience.
- Inform the family with consent where possible, and document everything.
Principles: least restrictive option, proportionality, necessity, dignity, and the patient's rights. Restrictive practice is a clinical intervention with legal and ethical safeguards, not a behavioural management tool. The nurse must also consider that his agitation may be driven by fear, untreated psychosis, or a physical cause - always rule out a medical cause such as infection, pain, or dehydration.