Two Drinks and a Lift Home
You are at a friend's house for a Friday evening meal. You drove there. Over about three hours you have had two beers with food. You feel fine - perhaps a little tired but not drunk. It is 11 p.m. and you have a 20-minute drive home on mostly quiet roads. Your friend says you can sleep on the sofa, but you have work at 7 a.m. and no clean clothes there. Another guest offers you a lift, but they have also been drinking. A taxi would take 25 minutes to arrive and cost more than you would like to spend.
1. Assess the options and identify the safest course of action, explaining the factors that affect how alcohol has acted on you.
Read the worked answer
Safest course: take the taxi, or sleep on the sofa and leave early. Between those two, the taxi gets you home with clean clothes for work; the sofa is free but leaves you rushing. Either is safe; driving is not.
Why "I feel fine" is not a test:
- Alcohol impairs judgement and reaction time before you notice it. Feeling fine is itself an unreliable indicator.
- Two beers over three hours with food will produce a lower peak than two beers quickly, but the body clears alcohol at a roughly fixed rate - roughly one standard drink per hour for many people - and that rate varies with body weight, sex, age, liver health and fatigue.
- Tiredness compounds alcohol. At 11 p.m. after a long week, your reaction time is already reduced; alcohol adds to that. The combination is more dangerous than either alone.
- Food slows absorption but does not remove alcohol already absorbed.
The other guest's offer: they have been drinking too. Decline. Two impaired drivers do not make one safe one.
The cost argument: a taxi fare is small against the consequences of a collision - injury, licence loss, insurance, and the risk to others.
2. Suppose you decide to drive anyway. What specific errors of judgement would you be making, and what would you be risking beyond your own safety?
Read the worked answer
Errors of judgement:
- Treating feeling as evidence. Subjective sobriety is not a measurement. You cannot feel your own reaction time.
- Discounting fatigue. Late night plus alcohol is a compounding risk you are ignoring.
- Underweighting the base rate. Quiet roads are not safe roads - they invite higher speeds and the few vehicles present may be less predictable.
- Anchoring on cost and convenience. You are weighing a taxi fare against a risk you have mentally minimised.
What you risk beyond yourself:
- Other road users - pedestrians, cyclists, and the driver of the one other car you meet.
- Your passengers, if any.
- Your licence, your livelihood if you drive for work, and your insurance.
- Legal consequences: driving while over the limit carries serious penalties.
The correct decision was made before you got in the car: arrange a lift, a taxi, or a place to stay before you drink. Once you have been drinking, the only reliable rule is not to drive.