Coolant Temperature Alarm on a Diesel Generator
A ship's auxiliary diesel generator trips on a high-coolant-temperature alarm during a drill. The engine had been running at 80% load for two hours. The coolant expansion tank level is normal, the raw-water sea strainer is clean, and the coolant temperature gauge reads 104 °C just before the trip. The raw-water pump impeller was last inspected 400 running hours ago, against a 500-hour service interval. The freshwater coolant was changed six months ago. The engine room ambient temperature is 48 °C, well above the 35 °C design point. A junior rating says the fix is simply to top up the coolant, since 'temperature problems are always about low coolant.'
1. Evaluate the junior rating's diagnosis and identify which observations most strongly argue against it.
Read the worked answer
The rating's diagnosis (low coolant) is weak because the expansion tank level is normal and there is no reported leak. If coolant were low, the level would drop and the gauge would typically spike faster. The strongest contrary evidence: (1) normal coolant level, (2) clean strainer ruling out blocked raw-water flow, (3) high ambient temperature (48 °C vs 35 °C design) which reduces heat-rejection margin, and (4) the impeller is at 400 of 500 hours - within interval but ageing. Topping up coolant would not address any of these. The likely cause is degraded heat rejection, not coolant loss.
2. The crew must decide whether to run the generator at reduced load or shut it down until the impeller is replaced. Recommend a course of action and justify it with the evidence given.
Read the worked answer
The evidence points to marginal cooling capacity rather than a single hard failure: coolant is present, strainer is clean, ambient is above design, and the impeller is within but approaching its service limit. Shutting down entirely is the safest choice if the generator is non-essential; if it is essential, running at reduced load (say ≤50%) lowers heat input and buys time. The impeller should be replaced early (before the 500-hour mark) because it is the most plausible degraded component. Recommendation: replace the impeller and, until then, run at reduced load only if operationally necessary, monitoring coolant temperature continuously. Justification: no single catastrophic fault is present, but multiple margins are eroded, so the prudent call is to remove the most likely degraded part and limit thermal stress meanwhile.
3. Explain why 'high ambient temperature' matters physically, in one or two sentences suitable for a training note.
Read the worked answer
A heat exchanger rejects heat to the surrounding air/water; the rate of rejection depends on the temperature difference between the coolant and the cooling medium. If ambient air is 48 °C instead of 35 °C, that difference shrinks, so the same hardware rejects less heat and coolant temperature rises even when nothing is broken.