Motorway breakdown with a child in the car
It is 15:00 on a dry day. You are on a three-lane motorway in the right-hand lane at 110 km/h when the engine loses power and a red battery warning light comes on. You manage to coast onto the hard shoulder and stop about 80 m past an emergency refuge area, facing the direction of traffic. In the car with you are your partner and a 6-year-old child. Traffic in the right-hand lane is heavy and passing at speed. The nearest emergency telephone is at the refuge area behind you. You have a warning triangle, a hi-vis vest and a first-aid kit in the boot. Your phone shows a weak signal.
1. Set out the correct order of actions from the moment you stop, and explain why each step is in that order.
Read the worked answer
Order matters because the greatest danger is being struck on the hard shoulder.
- Stop as far left as possible, wheels straight, handbrake on, hazard lights on immediately. Straight wheels mean that if the car is hit from behind it is pushed forward along the shoulder rather than into live lanes.
- Get everyone out on the left-hand side, away from traffic - never into the carriageway. Adults first to supervise, child held firmly by the hand.
- Put on the hi-vis vests before stepping out if you can reach them safely from inside the car; if they are in the boot, have one adult get them out while the others stay behind the barrier.
- Move everyone behind the safety barrier and well back from the vehicle, then walk to the refuge area.
- Call for help from the emergency telephone at the refuge area, not from the car. The phone identifies your location automatically, which a mobile call does not.
- Place the warning triangle only if it is genuinely safe - on a motorway hard shoulder this is often more dangerous than useful, and it is not required if you are behind the barrier and have called for help. Never walk into a live lane to place it.
The child is the priority: a 6-year-old cannot be relied on to stay put, so an adult must hold them at all times behind the barrier.
2. Your phone has a weak signal. Explain the practical advantage of walking back to the emergency telephone, including the distance involved and the risk this walk carries.
Read the worked answer
Advantage: the emergency telephone connects directly to the operator, identifies the exact marker post and carriageway, and works when the mobile network is weak. That removes the risk of a dropped call and of giving an imprecise location - on a motorway, 'about 80 m past a refuge area' is not a location an operator can act on quickly.
Distance: you are ~80 m past the refuge area, so it is roughly an 80 m walk back along the verge - not along the hard shoulder itself.
Risk: walking on the hard shoulder is one of the most dangerous things you can do on a motorway. Mitigate it by walking behind the safety barrier, on the grass or verge, wearing the hi-vis vest, facing oncoming traffic, and never stepping onto the carriageway. If the barrier is continuous and the walk would force you onto the shoulder, stay put, keep everyone behind the barrier, and keep trying the mobile - a precise description of the marker post you can see is the next best thing.
3. A recovery vehicle arrives and the driver offers to tow your car with a rope to the next exit, 4 km away, with your family inside the car. Assess this offer.
Read the worked answer
Refuse to carry passengers in a rope-towed car on a motorway.
- A rope tow gives no braking assistance and no steering assistance once the engine is off; the towed driver has to brake far earlier and cannot steer precisely. On a motorway at traffic speed this is a serious hazard.
- Passengers in a towed vehicle on a motorway multiply the risk: if the rope slackens and snaps, or the towed car is struck, there is no protection.
- The safe arrangement is a proper recovery onto a flatbed or a rigid tow bar, with all occupants travelling in the recovery vehicle, not in the towed car.
If only a rope tow to the next exit is available, the correct answer is: family travels in the recovery vehicle (or waits behind the barrier for a second vehicle), and the tow is done at low speed with hazard lights on. Do not accept a motorway rope tow with a child in the car.