The Well That Everyone Drinks From
You are the community health nurse in a semi-urban settlement of 8,000 people. The main water source is a communal well with a hand pump; 60% of households also use pit latrines within 10 metres of the well. Over 6 weeks, the health post has seen 47 cases of diarrhoea in children under 5, compared with 12 in the previous 6 weeks. Stool samples from 5 children grew a pathogen consistent with a waterborne source. The local authority owns the well and says repairs and relocation are 'not a priority this year'. A small factory upstream discharges waste into the same groundwater area. Residents say they cannot afford bottled water and have no alternative source.
1. Assess the environmental health risks and explain the chain of transmission.
Read the worked answer
Risk assessment
- Source contamination: pit latrines within 10 metres of the well are a classic contamination pathway, especially with a shallow hand-pump well. Upstream factory discharge adds a chemical and microbiological hazard.
- Exposure: 8,000 people, with 60% of households using nearby latrines, and no affordable alternative water source - exposure is universal and unavoidable.
- Outcome: 47 cases in under-5s versus 12 previously is a near four-fold increase; the pathogen isolated in 5 children supports a waterborne route.
Chain of transmission
- Agent: pathogen from human excreta (and possibly factory waste) entering groundwater.
- Reservoir: latrine pits and contaminated soil/groundwater.
- Portal of exit: faeces.
- Mode of transmission: contaminated well water ingested directly, and possibly via food prepared with that water or via hands.
- Portal of entry: mouth.
- Susceptible host: young children, who have lower immunity and higher water intake relative to body weight.
Key point: breaking the chain at any link reduces cases, but the most effective single intervention is making the water safe at the point of use.
2. What control measures would you recommend in the short term, given that the authority will not act?
Read the worked answer
Short-term measures (household and community level)
- Point-of-use treatment: distribute chlorine tablets or solution and teach correct dosing; promote boiling where fuel is available. This is the fastest way to reduce cases without waiting for the authority.
- Safe storage: provide or promote narrow-mouth containers with a tap or ladle to prevent recontamination after treatment.
- Hand hygiene: set up handwashing stations with soap at the health post, schools, and communal points; teach handwashing after latrine use and before food preparation.
- Case management: ensure oral rehydration salts and zinc are available at the health post and with community health workers; educate families on danger signs.
- Surveillance: continue weekly case counts to measure whether the interventions work.
- Protect the well now: ensure the well head is sealed and drained, and that no new latrines are dug within the safe distance.
Advocacy
- Present the case data and the isolated pathogen to the local authority in writing, with a specific, costed request (well head repair, latrine relocation support).
- Engage community leaders and residents to raise the issue collectively.
- Refer the factory discharge to the environmental health authority for investigation.
Evaluation: track weekly under-5 diarrhoea cases; a fall in cases after chlorination supports the waterborne hypothesis and strengthens the case for permanent works.
3. How would you engage the community so that the measures are adopted and sustained?
Read the worked answer
Engagement approach
- Start with listening: meet residents and community leaders to understand why the well is used (cost, distance, habit) and what they would accept.
- Co-design: involve residents in choosing the treatment method and storage container, and in deciding where handwashing stations go. Ownership predicts sustainability.
- Use existing structures: work through community health workers, women's groups, schools, and religious leaders rather than creating a new committee.
- Demonstrate: show visibly that treated water is safe (e.g., simple chlorine residual demonstration) so the benefit is credible.
- Address cost: negotiate subsidised chlorine supply or a community fund; free bottled water is not a realistic long-term answer.
- Feedback loop: share the weekly case numbers with the community so they can see the effect of their actions.
- Plan for handover: train local volunteers to continue distribution and monitoring after the campaign.
Ethical note: do not make residents feel blamed for using the only water available. The problem is structural; the community is part of the solution, not the cause.