Child with school refusal and separation anxiety
A 9-year-old boy is brought by his mother because he has refused to go to school for the past 3 weeks. He complains of stomachaches and headaches every morning before school. He cries and clings to his mother. He has always been shy and has few friends. His mother reports that he worries about her getting into an accident and checks on her frequently. He sleeps in his parents' bed most nights. His school performance is good when he attends, but he has missed 15 days this term. There is no history of trauma or bullying. His developmental history is normal. His mother is anxious and admits she feels guilty leaving him.
1. What is your diagnostic formulation and differential diagnosis?
Read the worked answer
Diagnostic formulation:
- The boy presents with separation anxiety disorder (SAD): excessive distress upon separation from attachment figures, worry about harm befalling them, refusal to sleep alone, and physical symptoms when separated. The school refusal is a manifestation of SAD.
- Differential diagnosis:
- Generalized anxiety disorder: Worry about multiple domains, but here the focus is separation.
- Social anxiety disorder: Shyness and few friends, but the primary fear is separation, not social evaluation.
- Specific phobia (school): Unlikely; he does not fear school itself but leaving his mother.
- Depression: Can cause school refusal, but no other depressive symptoms.
- Oppositional defiant disorder: Not consistent; he is anxious, not defiant.
- Bullying or trauma: Denied by history.
- Medical causes: Stomachaches and headaches are common somatic symptoms of anxiety; rule out physical causes if persistent.
- Contributing factors: Maternal anxiety and reinforcement of avoidance (sleeping in parents' bed, allowing school refusal) may maintain the behavior.
Key point: SAD is common in this age group and often presents with school refusal. Early intervention is important to prevent chronic anxiety and academic difficulties.
2. What treatment approach would you recommend, and how would you involve the parents?
Read the worked answer
Treatment approach:
- Psychoeducation: Explain SAD to the child and parents; normalize anxiety and emphasize that avoidance worsens anxiety.
- Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT): For the child, including relaxation training, cognitive restructuring, and gradual exposure to separation (e.g., sleeping alone, going to school).
- Parent involvement: Essential. Address maternal anxiety and guilt; encourage parents to support gradual return to school and independent sleeping. Reduce accommodation (e.g., sleeping in parents' bed).
- School liaison: Work with school to support gradual return, perhaps starting with partial days.
- Medication: SSRIs (e.g., fluoxetine) may be considered if symptoms are severe and impairing, but first-line is psychotherapy. In this case, given the duration and impairment, an SSRI could be considered if CBT is insufficient.
- Family therapy: May help address family dynamics maintaining anxiety.
Plan:
- Refer for CBT with a child psychologist.
- Meet with parents to discuss a behavioral plan: gradually reduce co-sleeping, set morning routine, and use rewards for school attendance.
- Coordinate with school for a gradual re-entry plan.
- Monitor progress; if no improvement after 8–12 weeks, consider fluoxetine.
Key point: Parental anxiety and accommodation are common maintaining factors; addressing them is crucial.