The Sold-Out Show With a Broken Lift
You are the front-of-house manager for a 1,200-seat venue. It is 6:45 pm, the show is sold out, and the main passenger lift has failed, trapping no one but leaving the balcony accessible only by two flights of stairs. The balcony holds 400 seats. Among the audience already arriving are several wheelchair users, a group from a residential care home with walking frames, and a patron with a broken leg in a moon boot. The venue's accessibility policy says wheelchair spaces are on the balcony. The ground floor has 800 seats and a flat floor. The show's licence requires a minimum number of accessible seats. The lift contractor says the earliest repair is tomorrow. Doors open at 7:00 pm and the show starts at 7:30 pm.
1. Explain the legal and ethical obligations at play and how they shape your options.
Read the worked answer
The obligations are anti-discrimination law, the venue's own accessibility policy, and the licensing conditions, plus a duty of care to patrons.
Anti-discrimination law requires that a person with a disability not be treated less favourably, and that reasonable adjustments be made. Telling a wheelchair user 'the balcony is your only option and the lift is broken' is not a reasonable adjustment; it is exclusion. The venue must do what is reasonable in the circumstances to provide equivalent access.
The accessibility policy placing wheelchair spaces on the balcony was written assuming a working lift. When the lift fails, the policy's purpose - access - cannot be met on the balcony, so the adjustment is to relocate accessible seating to the ground floor, which is flat and step-free.
The licence sets a minimum number of accessible seats. Relocating to the ground floor can still satisfy the spirit and usually the letter of the licence if the same number of spaces is provided, but you must check the licence wording and tell the regulator or licensing authority if the configuration changes.
Ethically, the residential care group and the patron in the moon boot face the same barrier. The test is whether a patron can get to a seat safely and with dignity, not whether they can manage the stairs.
2. Set out your action plan for the next forty-five minutes, including how you communicate with affected patrons.
Read the worked answer
Reconfigure the ground floor. Reserve a block of accessible spaces with companion seats and clear sightlines, remove or relocate the seats in that block, and brief ushers on the new layout.
Staff the entrance. Put a trained staff member at the door from 7:00 pm to identify patrons who cannot use the stairs, offer the ground-floor seats and personally escort them.
Communicate proactively. Contact ticket holders flagged in the booking system as needing accessible seating before they arrive if possible. Put a clear sign at the entrance and make a brief, non-stigmatising announcement.
Offer alternatives where the ground floor is not what the patron wants: a refund, a ticket exchange, or assisted access up the stairs where the patron chooses it and it is safe to do so. Never lift a patron or their wheelchair manually.
Manage the balcony. Stair access for ambulant patrons is fine, but allow extra time, light the stairs, and place stewards at the top and bottom. Consider delaying the start by ten minutes to let the audience settle.
Log and follow up. Record the lift failure, the actions taken, the patrons affected and any complaints. Notify the venue manager and the lift contractor in writing, and review the accessibility policy so it has a lift-failure procedure.