The Overlapping Shift at the Boulangerie
Léa, 17, is in Terminale in Rennes and works Saturday mornings at her uncle's boulangerie for 45 euros per shift. Her best friend Inès has just invited her to a birthday picnic in Nantes on a Saturday, and the train returns at 19:40. Léa's mother says schoolwork must come first; her uncle says he cannot open without her because the other apprentice quit in March. Léa has an oral French assessment the following Monday and has not yet written her 250-word script. She also promised Inès she would help set up the picnic. Léa feels torn between loyalty to family, friendship and her own academic goals, and she has not told anyone that she is exhausted and sleeping badly.
1. Identify the competing obligations in this situation and explain, in French suitable for a short written reflection, how Léa could prioritise them without breaking a promise.
Read the worked answer
The competing obligations are: family/work (the uncle depends on her; the boulangerie cannot open), friendship (Inès's birthday and the promise to help set up), and school (the Monday oral assessment and the unwritten script). A good answer names all three and notes the hidden fourth factor: her health and sleep.
A reasoned prioritisation: the assessment is fixed and non-negotiable, so it comes first. The shift is a commitment she made, so she should honour it or find a replacement - not simply cancel. The picnic is movable in part: she could attend after the shift if transport allows, or propose a second celebration.
Model French (reflection): « Je dois d'abord penser à l'évaluation de lundi, car elle est fixe. Ensuite, je ne peux pas laisser mon oncle sans aide : je chercherais quelqu'un pour me remplacer ou je proposerais de travailler le dimanche. Enfin, je dirais la vérité à Inès et je lui proposerais de fêter son anniversaire le week-end suivant. Une promesse se tient mieux quand on explique pourquoi on doit l'adapter. »
The judgement being tested is that honesty and renegotiation preserve relationships better than silent cancellation.
2. Léa decides to tell her uncle the truth about her exhaustion. Write four sentences in French she could say, using appropriate register for speaking to a close adult relative.
Read the worked answer
The register is familial but respectful - tu to an uncle she is close to, but no slang that would sound dismissive of his business.
Model answer: « Oncle Marc, il faut que je te parle franchement. En ce moment, je dors très mal et je suis épuisée, surtout le samedi après le lycée. J'ai aussi une évaluation orale lundi et je n'ai pas encore écrit mon texte. Est-ce qu'on pourrait trouver une solution ensemble, par exemple quelqu'un qui me remplace une semaine sur deux ? »
What earns marks: the il faut que + subjunctive structure, a clear statement of the problem, a concrete proposal, and a tone that respects his difficulty rather than accusing him. Avoid a blunt « je ne viens plus », which solves nothing and damages the relationship.