The Exchange Student's Timetable Clash
Lena, a Year 11 student, has just arrived in Hamburg on a three-week exchange. Her host mother hands her the school timetable and says the Sportverein training is Tuesdays and Thursdays at 17:00, but Lena's German class runs until 16:45 on those days and the bus to the sports hall takes 25 minutes. Her host brother Jonas, who is 16, offers to drive her, but only on Thursdays because he has Nachhilfe on Tuesdays. Lena also wants to join the school choir, which rehearses Wednesdays at 16:00 for 90 minutes. She has been told that punctuality matters a great deal in Germany and that arriving late to a club three times can mean losing the place. She is worried about her German homework, which takes her about 90 minutes each evening.
1. Can Lena realistically attend both the Sportverein and the choir? Justify your answer with the times given.
Read the worked answer
No, not both fully - she must choose or negotiate.
- Sportverein, Tuesday: class ends 16:45, bus takes 25 minutes → earliest arrival 17:10, already 10 minutes late. No lift from Jonas on Tuesdays. This is not sustainable.
- Sportverein, Thursday: Jonas drives her, so she can arrive on time. Thursday works.
- Choir, Wednesday: starts 16:00 and runs 90 minutes → ends 17:30. No clash with sport (sport is Tue/Thu), so choir is feasible.
So the realistic plan is choir on Wednesday plus Sportverein on Thursday only, and she should ask the trainer whether a Tuesday arrangement (e.g. a later group) exists. Attending only one sport session a week may not secure a place, so she needs to speak to the trainer directly rather than simply not turning up.
2. Lena's host mother says punctuality is 'very German'. How should Lena handle the Tuesday problem so she does not lose her place?
Read the worked answer
She should communicate in advance, not explain after the fact. German club culture generally accepts a known, agreed reason far better than repeated unexplained lateness.
A sensible sequence:
- Tell the trainer this week, in German, that her class ends at 16:45 and the bus takes 25 minutes, so she cannot be there before about 17:10 on Tuesdays.
- Ask a concrete question: whether she may join the Thursday group, or whether a later Tuesday session exists.
- Offer a solution - e.g. arriving as early as possible and apologising once, in advance.
Useful language: Ich habe dienstags bis 16:45 Unterricht und der Bus braucht 25 Minuten. Kann ich stattdessen donnerstags kommen? The key judgement is that a polite, early, specific request protects her place; silent lateness does not.
3. Estimate whether Lena's evening is overloaded, and suggest one adjustment.
Read the worked answer
Homework: about 90 minutes per evening. Choir Wednesday: 16:00–17:30, plus travel home. Sport Thursday: 17:00 start, plus travel home.
On Wednesday and Thursday she is out until roughly 17:30–18:00, so homework would begin around 18:30–19:00 and finish near 20:00–20:30 - tight but possible. The real risk is Tuesday, where a 17:10 arrival plus training plus the trip home pushes homework past 20:00 every week.
Adjustment: drop the Tuesday session and do the bulk of her German homework on Monday and Wednesday, keeping Tuesday free. She should also ask her teacher whether the 90 minutes can be split (30 minutes before school, 60 in the evening), which is a common and acceptable request.