The Client's Secret and the Duty to Report
Elena is a support worker visiting a 16-year-old client, Aisha, who receives disability support at home. During a visit, Aisha says her uncle 'gets angry and hits me sometimes' and shows Elena a bruise on her upper arm. Aisha begs Elena not to tell anyone, saying her family will be shamed and she will be blamed. Aisha's mother is present in the next room and does not know about the conversation. Elena's organisation has a child-safe policy and a mandatory reporting procedure. Elena is unsure whether the bruise is from the uncle or from something else, and Aisha will not say more.
1. Explain how Elena should respond to Aisha in the moment, including what she should and should not promise.
Read the worked answer
Elena should stay calm, listen without judgement, and thank Aisha for telling her. She should use open questions and not lead or pressure Aisha for details, because a rushed interrogation can distress the young person and contaminate any later investigation. She should not promise secrecy. A promise she cannot keep would damage trust and could mislead Aisha; instead she can say something honest such as, 'I can't keep this completely private because I have to make sure you're safe, but I'll only share it with the people who need to know to help you.'
She should acknowledge Aisha's fear about shame and blame without agreeing to hide the disclosure, and reassure her that Aisha has done nothing wrong. She should not confront the mother or the uncle, because that could escalate risk and interfere with the reporting process. She should record Aisha's exact words and the bruise factually as soon as practicable. The judgement is to be warm and honest, to avoid false assurances, and to keep the child's safety ahead of the family's wish for privacy.
2. What should Elena do next under the child-safe policy, and how should she handle the uncertainty about the cause of the bruise?
Read the worked answer
Elena should follow the organisation's child-safe and mandatory reporting procedure promptly. That typically means reporting the disclosure and observation to her supervisor or designated child-safety contact, who then determines whether a report to the statutory child protection authority is required. Elena should not investigate the matter herself or decide alone that it is 'probably nothing.'
The uncertainty about the cause does not justify delay. Mandatory reporting thresholds are based on reasonable suspicion or belief, not proof; it is the child protection authority's role to determine what happened. Elena should report the facts as she knows them, including that the cause is unclear and that Aisha would not say more, so the authority can assess accurately. She should document the time, the disclosure, the bruise, and the action taken, and share information only on a need-to-know basis, consistent with privacy law. The judgement tested is acting on reasonable suspicion, following the correct channel, and resisting the temptation to resolve the uncertainty before reporting.