A Hard Landing and the Reporting Decision
During a solo circuits session you land firmly on the main wheels. The touchdown feels hard, the aircraft bounces slightly, and you continue the landing without further incident. After shut-down you inspect the aircraft and find no visible damage, but the tyre shows a scuff mark and you are unsure whether the hard landing exceeded the aircraft's limits. The aircraft is due for its next periodic inspection in three weeks. The club has a defect reporting system and an occurrence reporting scheme. Another member tells you not to worry because nothing broke and the aircraft will be inspected soon anyway.
1. What should you do about the hard landing, and why?
Read the worked answer
You should report the hard landing to the operator or club and enter it in the aircraft documentation so that a qualified person can inspect the aircraft before it flies again. A hard landing can cause damage that is not visible externally, including to the landing gear attachments, engine mounts, propeller tips, and the airframe structure. The fact that no damage is visible is not evidence that none exists. The upcoming periodic inspection in three weeks is not a substitute, because the aircraft may fly many hours before then. The correct sequence is to ground the aircraft from your use, notify the person responsible for maintenance, and record what happened, including an honest description of the touchdown and the bounce.
2. Is this a reportable occurrence under an occurrence reporting scheme?
Read the worked answer
It may be. Occurrence reporting schemes generally capture accidents and serious incidents, and also incidents that could affect safety. A hard landing that requires inspection or that exceeds the aircraft's limits can fall within the definition of a reportable occurrence, particularly if damage is found. The prudent approach is to report it through the club's scheme and let the scheme decide whether it meets the threshold, rather than deciding yourself that it does not. Reporting is not an admission of fault; it is how safety information is gathered. The other member's advice to stay quiet is exactly the culture that hides developing problems. If in doubt, report and keep a copy.
3. How would you respond to the other member's advice?
Read the worked answer
Respond politely but firmly: the absence of visible damage does not mean the aircraft is serviceable, and the inspection schedule is not a licence to defer a known event. Point out that if the gear or mounts were damaged, the next pilot could be exposed to a failure, and that a report protects them as well as you. Explain that the reporting system exists to find problems early and that a report is a normal professional action, not an accusation. If the member persists, escalate to the club's safety officer or chief instructor. The aim is not to win an argument but to ensure the aircraft is inspected and the event is recorded.