Allergen Request During a Busy Lunch Service
It is 1:15 pm on a Saturday and a 90-seat cafe is full with a queue at the door. A table of four orders. One guest says she has a severe peanut allergy and asks whether the satay chicken burger is safe. The waiter tells her the kitchen "should be fine" because the satay sauce is made in-house. The kitchen has one wok station where satay is cooked, a shared grill, and a shared fryer. The peanut butter is stored in a large tub on the prep bench next to the mayonnaise. The cafe has no allergen matrix and staff have not been trained on allergen management. The guest is visibly anxious and says she has an EpiPen.
1. Assess the allergen risks in this scenario and explain what the waiter should have done instead of saying "should be fine".
Read the worked answer
The waiter's statement is unsafe because it is an assurance without evidence. Under the Food Standards Code, a food business must ensure food is safe and correctly described, and allergen information must be accurate. "Should be fine" is not an accurate answer when the kitchen has not assessed the risk.
Specific risks in this cafe:
- Shared wok and grill: satay cooked in the same wok or on the same grill as other food can transfer peanut protein to the guest's meal.
- Shared fryer: oil can carry allergen proteins from one food to another.
- Open peanut butter tub on the prep bench: this creates a cross-contact risk for any food prepared nearby, including the mayonnaise.
- No allergen matrix: staff cannot reliably tell the guest which dishes contain peanut.
- No training: the waiter did not know how to escalate the question.
The correct approach is for the waiter to tell the guest honestly that the kitchen cannot guarantee the dish is peanut-free, take the query to the chef, and offer safe alternatives. The chef should check the recipe and preparation method, decide whether the dish can be made safely, and if not, tell the guest clearly. The guest should never be given a false assurance. If the guest chooses to eat, the business should still minimise risk by using clean utensils, a clean pan, and fresh oil where possible, and by documenting the request.
2. Recommend the changes the cafe should make to its allergen management system, and explain how the staff should respond if the guest has a reaction at the table.
Read the worked answer
The cafe should build a formal allergen management system:
- Allergen matrix: list every menu item against the major allergens (peanut, tree nuts, milk, egg, wheat, soy, fish, shellfish, sesame, lupin) and update it whenever recipes change.
- Supplier verification: keep labels and specifications for all bought-in products, including sauces and mayonnaise.
- Storage separation: store peanut butter in a sealed, labelled container away from ready-to-eat items, ideally on a lower shelf and in a separate area.
- Separation of equipment: designate a clean pan, board, and utensils for allergen-free orders, or use a dedicated fryer.
- Training: train all staff on allergens, cross-contact, how to answer questions, and how to escalate to the chef.
- Communication script: staff should say, "I will check with the chef," not "should be fine".
- Order flagging: mark allergen orders clearly on dockets and have the chef confirm the dish before it leaves the pass.
If the guest has a reaction at the table:
- Call an ambulance immediately if there are signs of anaphylaxis such as difficulty breathing, swelling of the throat, or collapse.
- Help the guest use their EpiPen if they have one and cannot do it themselves, following their instructions.
- Keep the guest lying down or seated as appropriate and do not leave them alone.
- Preserve the meal and packaging for investigation.
- Record the incident and notify the owner and, where required, the food authority.