The Unprepared Topic Card
In the oral examination, students receive a topic card and have a short preparation time before speaking. Nadia receives the topic 'A time when you had to solve a problem'. She has 5 minutes to prepare. She spends 4 minutes writing full sentences in Arabic, then reads them aloud almost word for word for 2 minutes. Her delivery is halting because she is reading her own handwriting. When the assessor asks a follow-up question about how she felt during the problem, she cannot answer because her notes do not cover feelings. She has strong vocabulary but her preparation method has worked against her.
1. Explain why Nadia's preparation method is counterproductive and what it reveals about her understanding of the task.
Read the worked answer
Nadia treats preparation as scriptwriting rather than idea organisation. Writing full sentences uses most of her 5 minutes and produces a text she then reads, which explains the halting delivery: she is decoding handwriting rather than speaking. Reading aloud also prevents natural intonation and eye contact, both of which affect delivery.
More seriously, her notes cover only events, not feelings, so she cannot answer the follow-up about how she felt. This reveals that she has not anticipated the range of questions the topic invites. A topic about solving a problem naturally invites reflection on emotions, lessons learned, and alternatives. Her method leaves no room for this because it fixes content in advance.
Preparation time should generate keywords and structure, not a transcript.
2. Describe a better 5-minute preparation routine for Nadia, with a rationale for each step.
Read the worked answer
Minutes 1–2: Identify the story and its shape. Choose one specific problem, not a general one. Note four keywords: situation, problem, action, result. A specific story is easier to narrate and more engaging.
Minutes 2–3: Add reflection. Note two keywords for feelings ('worried', 'relieved') and one for a lesson ('I learned to...'). This directly prepares her for follow-up questions about emotion and reflection.
Minutes 3–4: Prepare flexible phrases. Note 3–4 useful expressions such as 'At first I didn't know what to do' and 'In the end...'. These are reusable across topics and support spontaneous speech.
Minute 4–5: Rehearse silently. Say the story once in her head without writing, checking the sequence. This builds fluency and leaves her free to speak rather than read.
The routine replaces a fixed script with a flexible framework, so she can respond to follow-ups.