A Café Deciding How to Source and Market Its Produce
A café sources tomatoes, lettuce and eggs. Option 1 is a large wholesaler: cheaper, consistent quality, year-round supply, but produce travels long distances and the café cannot verify farming practices. Option 2 is a nearby farm: produce is seasonal, sometimes limited, about 25% more expensive, but the farmer allows visits and uses practices the owner can observe. The café's customers are mostly local workers who value speed and price, but a growing number ask about where food comes from. The café's food cost is currently 32% of revenue and the owner wants to keep it under 35%.
1. Evaluate the two sourcing options against the café's financial and ethical goals, and recommend a strategy.
Read the worked answer
Financial: the café needs food cost under 35% of revenue, currently 32%. Switching entirely to the farm would raise costs by about 25% on those items, which could push food cost toward or past the limit depending on how much of the menu uses them. The wholesaler protects the margin and guarantees supply.
Ethical and quality: the farm offers traceability, observed practices, freshness and a story the owner can verify. The wholesaler offers no such assurance, and long-distance transport has environmental costs.
Customer expectations: most customers value speed and price, but a growing group asks about provenance. Ignoring them risks losing that segment; serving only premium local food risks losing price-sensitive customers.
Recommendation: a mixed strategy - source high-profile items such as tomatoes and eggs from the farm and promote them clearly on the menu, while keeping stable, lower-cost items from the wholesaler. This keeps food cost within the target, preserves supply reliability, and gives the provenance-minded customers something concrete, without forcing all customers to pay more.
2. Explain how the café could communicate its sourcing honestly without misleading customers or raising costs excessively.
Read the worked answer
Honest communication depends on claims being specific, accurate and verifiable.
- Be specific: instead of 'locally sourced', name the farm and the items it supplies, and state that other items come from a wholesaler. Vague claims invite suspicion and may breach consumer law if they imply more than is true.
- Use low-cost channels: menu notes, a chalkboard, social media posts and staff briefing cost little. Staff should be able to answer 'where is this from?' accurately.
- Avoid overclaiming: terms like 'organic' or 'free range' should only be used if certified or genuinely true; otherwise describe what is actually known, such as 'grown by [farm], 20 km away'.
- Manage seasonality honestly: when the farm cannot supply, say so rather than quietly substituting and leaving the claim in place.
This approach builds trust with provenance-minded customers at minimal cost and protects the café legally, because the claims match what is actually served.