A Rising Gross Margin That Hides a Problem
Harbourline Retail reports: gross profit margin rising from 32% to 38% over two years, while inventory turnover falls from 8.0 to 5.2 times. The current ratio is 1.9, but the quick ratio is 0.6. Receivables days have risen from 35 to 62. The business switched from FIFO to a weighted average cost method in the current year, which reduced closing inventory by $40,000 relative to FIFO. Sales grew 4%, but operating cash flow fell 30%. The bank covenant requires a quick ratio above 0.8. Management argues the higher gross margin proves improved buying.
1. Interpret the ratio movements and assess management's claim.
Read the worked answer
The margin rise is not evidence of better buying. Inventory turnover falling from 8.0 to 5.2 means stock sits far longer, and with rising receivables days (35 to 62) cash is increasingly tied up in working capital, explaining the 30% fall in operating cash flow despite 4% sales growth. A gross margin can rise because slow-moving stock is capitalised rather than written down, or because prices were raised while volume stagnated.
The method change complicates comparability: weighted average reduced closing inventory by $40,000 versus FIFO, which should lower profit, yet margin rose - suggesting the underlying margin improvement is even smaller than reported, or that old, unsold stock is being carried at stale costs. The quick ratio of 0.6 against a 1.9 current ratio shows liquidity depends on inventory that is not moving. Management's claim is unsupported; the pattern is consistent with obsolete stock and weak cash conversion.
2. Explain the covenant risk and recommend two actions.
Read the worked answer
The quick ratio of 0.6 is below the 0.8 covenant, so the bank could demand repayment or reprice the facility. The current ratio looks healthy only because slow inventory inflates current assets; if stock is written down, both ratios fall further.
Actions: (1) Run an aged stock analysis and write down or discount obsolete lines, accepting a one-off margin hit to restore turnover and cash; (2) Tighten credit control - invoice promptly, set credit limits, offer early-settlement discounts - to bring receivables days back toward 35. A third option is to renegotiate the covenant proactively with the bank, presenting a recovery plan. Disclosing the accounting policy change and its $40,000 effect is essential for comparability.