The Trespasser Who Won't Leave
You are a uniformed guard at a shopping center in Mesa. At 1530 a store manager points out a man, roughly 6 feet tall, carrying a backpack, who has been asked to leave twice this week for panhandling near the entrance. The manager says, 'Get him off the property, he's scaring customers.' You approach and tell the man he must leave. He becomes loud, steps within arm's length of you, and says, 'You can't touch me, you're not a cop.' He is not touching anyone and has not threatened violence. A crowd of about 15 shoppers has stopped to watch. Your company policy permits hands-on force only to prevent imminent harm to persons or property, and requires disengagement when feasible.
1. What legal authority do you have here, and what are its limits?
Read the worked answer
Your authority is essentially the property owner's authority, delegated to you: the right to control who remains on private property. That supports asking him to leave and, if he refuses, contacting police for criminal trespass. It does not make you a peace officer. You have no arrest power beyond what any private citizen has, and no authority to search him or demand ID.
Limits that matter right now:
- No force for disrespect. 'You can't touch me' is not an offense. Verbal defiance alone justifies nothing physical.
- Force only for imminent harm. Company policy matches the general rule: physical force is defensible to stop an immediate threat to people or property, not to enforce a request.
- Proportionality. Even if he shoved you, your response must be reasonable in light of the threat - a 6-foot man with a backpack and no weapon does not justify a strike or a takedown over a panhandling complaint.
- Crowd effect. 15 onlookers raises the risk of escalation and of someone recording a bad decision. Distance and time are your tools.
2. Give your next three actions in order, with the reasoning for each.
Read the worked answer
1. Create distance and stop negotiating in a crowd. Step back to at least two arm-lengths and angle toward an exit. Reason: he closed to arm's length once, and the audience rewards him for standing his ground. Distance buys reaction time and removes the performance.
2. Restate the request once, plainly, with a consequence you can actually deliver. 'You need to leave the property now. If you don't, I'm calling police for trespass and they'll remove you.' Reason: this is the lawful path - the property owner's remedy for refusal is police, not your hands. It also gives him a face-saving exit.
3. If he refuses, call police and disengage. Move to a position where you can observe him without blocking his path, keep the manager informed, and wait. Reason: policy requires disengagement when feasible, and it is feasible here - no one is being harmed. Do not follow him off property, do not grab the backpack, do not stand chest-to-chest.
If he walks away: let him. Log the time, description, and the two prior requests. That record is what supports a trespass charge next time.