Kgotla Furniture: Choosing a Business Form
Four friends in Palapye want to start Kgotla Furniture, making school desks. They need P250,000 for machinery and a workshop. Between them they have P90,000. Two of them, Neo and Tshepo, will work full time; the other two will invest money but keep their government jobs. A local buyer wants a P180,000 order delivered in four months, but will only sign if the business can show it is a registered legal entity with limited liability, because the buyer's procurement rules require this. A bank has offered a loan of P160,000, but only to a registered company, and requires personal guarantees from two directors. The friends are arguing about whether to register as a partnership or a company.
1. Compare a partnership and a private company for Kgotla Furniture, and recommend which form they should choose.
Read the worked answer
Partnership
- Quick and cheap to form; few legal formalities.
- Can raise capital from up to 20 partners and share the workload.
- But partners have unlimited liability - personal assets are at risk if the business fails.
- It is not a separate legal person, so the buyer's procurement requirement would not be met.
- Disagreements between partners can paralyse decisions, and the two silent partners would still carry liability.
Private company (Pty Ltd)
- Separate legal identity and limited liability, satisfying the buyer.
- Can issue shares, so the two non-working investors can hold shares without being involved in management.
- Perpetual succession - the business continues if a shareholder leaves or dies.
- The bank will lend to it, though the personal guarantees reduce the protection for Neo and Tshepo.
- Costs more to register and must comply with filing and accounting requirements.
Judgement: the company is clearly better here. The decisive factor is not tax or cost but access: without limited liability the P180,000 order and the P160,000 loan are both lost. The extra registration cost is trivial beside those sums. They should register the company, issue shares in proportion to contribution, and write a shareholders' agreement covering how the two non-working investors can exit.
2. The bank requires personal guarantees from Neo and Tshepo. Explain the risk this creates and suggest how the friends should manage it.
Read the worked answer
A personal guarantee means that if the company cannot repay the loan, the bank can pursue Neo and Tshepo personally for the debt, using their homes, savings or other assets. This removes much of the benefit of limited liability for the two people who are already taking the greatest risk by giving up paid employment.
How to manage it:
- Share the guarantee fairly. The two investor-shareholders benefit from the loan too, so they should either co-guarantee or accept a larger share of any loss.
- Negotiate the guarantee's scope - cap it at a stated amount, or limit it to the first two years, rather than an open-ended liability.
- Reduce the loan. If the investors increase their contribution, the loan falls and so does the guaranteed amount.
- Formalise it in writing through a shareholders' agreement, so that if the guarantee is ever called on, Neo and Tshepo have a claim against the company and the other shareholders.
- Protect cash flow by securing a deposit from the school-desk buyer, so the loan is not needed to fund work in progress.
Judgement: the guarantee is acceptable only if the order is confirmed in writing first and a deposit is received. Taking the guarantee before the order is signed would put Neo and Tshepo's homes at risk for a business that may have no customer.