The Mosquito Net Decision
A village of 600 people has a high rate of malaria. Most cases are in children under five and pregnant women. The nearest clinic is 20 km away. A charity offers either 200 insecticide-treated bed nets or a supply of antimalarial drugs to treat 100 cases. The village has no reliable supply of clean water, and many homes have open water containers and gaps in walls. Some villagers say nets are uncomfortable and they will not use them. A health worker must decide how to spend the limited aid and how to persuade people to use it.
1. Compare the two options and recommend how the aid should be used, with reasons.
Read the worked answer
Bed nets are the stronger choice for prevention. Insecticide-treated nets protect the person sleeping under them and, if enough households use them, reduce the number of mosquitoes in the village, so they lower new infections over time. They protect the groups at greatest risk, especially children under five and pregnant women, and they need no diagnosis or trained staff. Treating 100 cases helps 100 sick people but does not stop transmission, and the drugs will be used up while new infections continue. A better plan is to buy the nets and also use any remaining funds for a small stock of drugs for confirmed cases. The nets should be prioritised for households with young children and pregnant women. Prevention reduces the number of people who need treatment, so over months the nets save more lives than the drugs alone.
2. The villagers are reluctant to use the nets. Suggest practical measures to increase use, and explain why each would work.
Read the worked answer
- Involve respected local people, such as village elders and mothers, to demonstrate how to hang the net and explain that it prevents illness, not just mosquitoes. People are more likely to accept advice from trusted neighbours than outsiders. 2) Show that the nets are comfortable: hang them properly so they do not touch the skin, and explain that the insecticide is safe when used as directed. This removes the practical reason for refusal. 3) Combine nets with removing standing water from open containers and closing gaps in walls, which reduces mosquito breeding and entry so people see fewer mosquitoes and believe the effort works. 4) Link net use to protecting children and pregnant women, which appeals to family duty. 5) Monitor use and give feedback, so the community sees the fall in malaria cases and keeps using the nets.
3. Explain why the village's water supply and housing affect the malaria problem.
Read the worked answer
Malaria is spread by female mosquitoes of the genus Anopheles, which lay eggs in standing water. Open water containers, puddles and poorly drained ground near homes provide breeding sites, so more mosquitoes are produced close to where people sleep. Gaps in walls and unscreened windows let mosquitoes indoors at night, when the insects are most active and people are asleep and unprotected. A reliable clean water supply would reduce the need to store water in open containers, removing breeding sites, and would also reduce other water-borne diseases. Better housing with screens and closed eaves reduces indoor biting. So the malaria rate is not only a matter of medicine: it is shaped by the physical environment, and improving water storage and housing is part of control.