The Morning Announcement: Who Goes Where?
At a rural primary school, the teacher reads the morning announcement once, at normal speed, then puts the paper away. The announcement is: 'Kamoso ka 7:00 phakela, bana ba ba nang le lokwalo lwa go duela sekolo ba tla kopana kwa phaposing ya botlhano. Ba ba sa duelang ba ka ya kwa ofising ya mogokgo morago ga nako ya go ja. Mongwe le mongwe o tshwanetse go tsamaya ka bus ya 7:30.' (Tomorrow at 7:00 a.m., learners with a receipt for school payment meet in Room 5. Those who have not paid may go to the head teacher's office after lunch. Everyone must take the 7:30 bus.) Mpho has a receipt but arrives at 7:20. Tshepo's father paid yesterday, but Tshepo has no receipt. Lunch ends at 12:30, and the head teacher's office closes at 13:00.
1. Tshepo has no receipt. Using only the wording of the announcement, decide what he should do and identify the one point on which the announcement is genuinely silent.
Read the worked answer
The announcement sorts learners by whether they have 'lokwalo lwa go duela' - a payment document - not by whether they have actually paid. Tshepo has paid but has no document, so he fits neither group literally.
The reasonable action is to go to the head teacher's office after lunch, between 12:30 and 13:00, with his father's name or a note, rather than joining Room 5 at 7:00, because Room 5 is defined as the group holding the receipt.
The announcement is silent on learners who have paid but cannot prove it. That gap is what makes his case a judgement call; the safe reading is to seek confirmation instead of assuming exemption.
2. Mpho has a receipt but arrives at 7:20 and says she will skip the meeting so as not to miss the 7:30 bus. Evaluate her reasoning.
Read the worked answer
Her premise is right - the announcement sets both a 7:00 meeting and a 7:30 bus - but her conclusion does not follow.
The announcement never says the meeting ends before 7:30, so skipping it is a choice, not a requirement. Arriving at 7:20 already means she misses the opening. The sensible action is to report to Room 5, explain the bus time, and ask the teacher either to release her early or to confirm that the bus will wait.
The trap is treating two stated obligations as if one automatically cancels the other. A listener who does that has understood the words but not the situation.
3. Why does the position of 'morago ga nako ya go ja' matter to how the announcement is understood?
Read the worked answer
The phrase sits inside the second sentence and modifies only 'ba ba sa duelang' - those who have not paid. Learners with receipts are told to meet at 7:00; only the non-payers are told to go after lunch.
If a listener attaches the phrase to the whole announcement, everyone would think they may delay until after lunch, and the 7:00 meeting would empty. If a listener attaches it to the bus sentence, they would wrongly think the bus leaves after lunch.
This is a clause-attachment question, not a memory question: the words are known, but their scope decides who must be where and when.