The Inheritance File With a Missing Heir and a Debt
Notary Natallia opens an inheritance file after the death of Mrs K., who owned a flat worth 80,000 BYN, a car worth 12,000 BYN, and a bank deposit of 9,000 BYN. She also had a 30,000 BYN unpaid loan. Two sons have appeared. A third son, from a first marriage, is named in the will but his address is unknown; the will leaves him one-third of the flat. A creditor has written demanding payment within ten days. One son wants the flat sold immediately to pay the debt; the other wants to keep it. The notary must decide what protective measures to take and when to issue the certificate.
1. What protective measures over the inheritance should the notary take, and how should the creditor's demand be handled?
Read the worked answer
The notary's first duty is to preserve the estate until the heirs are determined.
Inventory and custody. The notary should draw up an inventory of the flat, the car, and the deposit, and take measures to preserve them: notify the bank to freeze the deposit pending determination, arrange custody of the car and its documents, and ensure the flat is secured and insured if necessary. These measures protect all heirs, including the absent son.
The creditor. The creditor's ten-day demand does not override the inheritance procedure. Debts of the deceased are paid by the heirs within the value of the estate, after the certificate is issued and the estate is determined. The notary should inform the creditor in writing that the estate is under administration, that the claim must be lodged in the file with supporting documents, and that payment will follow the lawful order. The notary must not pay the creditor directly from estate assets before the heirs are established.
The absent heir. The notary must take reasonable steps to locate the third son - requests to the address in the will, to the registry, and where permitted a public notice. Until he is found or lawfully represented, the certificate cannot be issued to the other two alone for his share.
The car and flat. The car should not be sold before the heirs agree or a court decides; the notary cannot choose between the sons' preferences.
2. When and to whom may the certificate of inheritance be issued, and how should the flat be dealt with if the heirs disagree?
Read the worked answer
Timing. The certificate is issued after the inheritance period expires and the circle of heirs is established. If the third son cannot be found, the notary should consider appointing a representative for the absent heir where the law allows, or suspend the file and direct the parties to court for a declaration. Issuing the certificate to two sons only would deprive the third of his share and expose the notary to liability.
Content. The certificate should identify each heir, the share (one-third of the flat to the third son, and the residue according to the will and law), and the assets. It must reflect the debt as an encumbrance to be settled within the value of the estate.
Disagreement over the flat. Co-heirs hold the flat in common. One cannot force a sale against the others outside the lawful procedure. The options are: (a) a notarised agreement on division, under which one son takes the flat and compensates the others; (b) sale by all co-heirs by common consent; or (c) a court action for division or for sale if agreement is impossible. The notary should explain these options and offer mediation, but must not certify a sale by only one son.
Debt. The 30,000 BYN debt is paid from the estate before distribution, or the heirs accept it proportionally. The notary should record the creditor's claim and ensure the division agreement accounts for it, so the sons do not distribute the estate and leave the creditor unpaid.