The Wedding Party and the Shots Tray
You are the only certified server on duty at a small banquet hall hosting a wedding reception of 90 guests. There are two bartenders and one server. At 10:15 p.m., a groomsman orders a tray of 12 tequila shots for the head table. Two of the men at that table are already loud, red-faced, and one has stumbled into a chair twice. The bride's father, who is paying, tells you, "It's my daughter's wedding, don't ruin it, just bring the tray." The venue's policy says no shot trays after 10 p.m. and no service to anyone showing impairment. Your manager stepped out to handle a parking issue and is not answering the radio.
1. Apply the policy and the law to the tray request, and identify the competing pressures.
Read the worked answer
The policy is clear on two independent grounds: it is after 10 p.m., and at least one recipient is visibly impaired. Either ground alone justifies refusing the tray. The law adds a third: serving an apparently intoxicated person creates liability for the venue and for you as the certified server, and a tray makes it easy to serve people you have not individually assessed.
Competing pressures: the payer is the bride's father, so refusing feels like defying the host; the event is celebratory and refusing may draw attention; you are short-staffed and the manager is unreachable; and a tray order is high-value. None of these change the standard. Money and occasion do not create an exception. The right call is to decline the tray, offer a substitute such as a round of non-alcoholic drinks or a limited number of drinks served individually after ID and assessment, and explain briefly and privately to the father that the venue's insurance and license require it.
2. The manager is unreachable. Describe your escalation and service plan for the rest of the night.
Read the worked answer
Escalate in parallel rather than waiting. Send the manager a text describing the refusal and the reason so there is a timestamped record. Tell the other bartender and server the plan so no one undercuts you by pouring the tray. Brief the groomsman privately: no tray, but drinks can be ordered individually, and anyone showing impairment will be cut off.
Service plan: switch the head table to table service so each person is assessed. Offer water and food prominently. Watch the two loud men closely and cut them off if they show more signs. Set a soft close for alcohol 30 minutes before the event ends. If the father pushes back again, stay calm and repeat the policy once, then disengage and let the manager follow up. Document times, names, signs, and actions. If anyone tries to drive impaired, follow the venue's transport protocol and call police if needed.