The Claim File That Went Quiet
Nadia is a claims adjuster at a Quebec insurer handling a $45,000 water-damage claim from a homeowner, Gilles. Six weeks after the loss, Gilles' contractor submits an estimate that includes upgrades not related to the damage. Nadia suspects inflation of the claim but has not yet spoken to Gilles about it. Meanwhile, Gilles' broker, Luc, calls Nadia asking for a status update and hints that Gilles is frustrated. Nadia is also aware that her supervisor has asked her to close files faster this quarter. She is tempted to deny the claim outright to meet the target.
1. What professional and ethical obligations govern Nadia's handling of the suspected inflated estimate?
Read the worked answer
Nadia must balance the insurer's interest with fairness to the insured.
- Duty of good faith: the insurer owes a duty of good faith and fair dealing to the insured. That means investigating before deciding, not denying on suspicion.
- Investigation: she should obtain competing estimates, ask the contractor to itemize the upgrades, and give Gilles a chance to explain. Suspicion alone is not a basis for denial.
- Fairness: if part of the claim is inflated, the proper response is to pay the covered portion and explain the reduction - not to deny the whole claim.
- Documentation: every step, including the request for itemization and Gilles' response, should be recorded.
- Referral: if fraud is suspected, she should follow the insurer's special investigation protocol rather than act alone.
2. How should Nadia respond to Luc's request for a status update?
Read the worked answer
Communication with the broker must be timely, accurate, and respectful of privacy.
- Timeliness: six weeks without contact is too long. Nadia should give Luc a clear status and a timeline for the next step.
- Accuracy: she should describe the investigation factually - that the estimate is under review and itemization has been requested - without accusing Gilles of fraud.
- Privacy: she may share claim information with the broker where the insured has authorized it, but she should not disclose suspicions or personal details beyond what is necessary.
- Written follow-up: Nadia should confirm the conversation by email so there is a record.
- Relationship: keeping Luc informed protects the broker-insurer relationship and reduces the risk of a bad-faith complaint.
3. How should Nadia handle the pressure to close files quickly?
Read the worked answer
Production pressure must not compromise the quality of the decision.
- Independence: Nadia must decide on the merits. Denying a claim to meet a target would be a serious breach of the duty of good faith and could expose the insurer to a bad-faith claim.
- Escalation: if the target conflicts with proper handling, she should raise it with her supervisor, documenting the conflict.
- Prioritization: she can close simple, well-documented files quickly while giving complex files the time they need.
- Professional standards: her conduct is governed by the applicable insurance professional standards, which require diligence, honesty, and fairness - not speed at any cost.
- Record: she should note the reasons for any delay in the file so the decision is defensible later.