The Claim That Arrived After the Deadline
Aisha holds a disability income policy with a 60-day elimination period and a clause requiring written proof of claim within 90 days of the start of disability, "or as soon as reasonably possible." She was injured on March 1 and submitted her claim on August 15, about 167 days after the injury. She explains that she was hospitalized, then moving between family homes, and did not understand the paperwork. The insurer denies the claim for late filing. Her employer confirms she was absent from work from March 2 onward. The policy also contains a clause allowing the insurer to require an independent medical examination.
1. Assess whether the late filing justifies denial, applying the policy wording.
Read the worked answer
The wording controls, and it is forgiving.
The clause requires proof within 90 days "or as soon as reasonably possible." That second phrase creates flexibility. A denial based purely on the 90-day target is weak if Aisha can show she filed as soon as reasonably possible.
Factors supporting Aisha:
- Hospitalization and housing instability are legitimate obstacles.
- The employer's records independently confirm the disability start date, so the insurer is not prejudiced by the delay.
- The insurer had the ability to investigate; late notice matters most when it prevents investigation.
Factors supporting the insurer:
- 167 days is a long delay, and a court may find that "reasonably possible" was earlier than August.
- Aisha's failure to read the paperwork is a weaker excuse than incapacity.
Likely outcome: A denial based solely on the deadline is vulnerable. The insurer should assess the claim on its merits, and Aisha should appeal with medical records and an explanation of her circumstances.
2. What procedural rights and obligations apply, and how should Aisha proceed?
Read the worked answer
Obligations on Aisha:
- Provide proof of claim - medical records, employer confirmation, and a written explanation of the delay.
- Attend an independent medical examination if requested. Refusing without good reason can jeopardize the claim.
- Cooperate with any rehabilitation or return-to-work assessment.
Rights and process:
- Request the denial in writing with the specific clause cited.
- Submit a formal appeal with supporting documents and a timeline of her hospitalization and moves.
- If the internal appeal fails, escalate to the insurer's ombudsman or the applicable regulator.
- Keep copies of everything and track deadlines for each stage.
Broker's role: Help assemble the file, frame the "reasonably possible" argument with evidence, and manage expectations honestly. The broker should not promise a reversal but should ensure the appeal is complete and timely.
The exam point: procedural clauses are read with their qualifiers, and prejudice to the insurer is central to whether late notice defeats a claim.