Fact, Opinion, and the Word "Best"
A class reads a student-written review of a new school lunch menu. The review says: "The new menu started on Monday. The pasta line was the longest line on the first day. The pasta is the best lunch in the whole school. Most students chose pasta on Monday. The salad bar is boring." The teacher asks students to separate facts from opinions and to explain how they know. One student says, "Everything with a number or a day is a fact." Another says, "Anything I agree with is a fact." The class must decide which statements are facts, which are opinions, and how a reader can tell the difference without relying on personal taste.
1. Sort the five statements into facts and opinions, and explain the clue words that helped you. Write 60-90 words.
Read the worked answer
Facts: "The new menu started on Monday" and "The pasta line was the longest line on the first day." These can be checked. "Most students chose pasta on Monday" is also a fact if it can be counted. Opinions: "The pasta is the best lunch in the whole school" and "The salad bar is boring." The words "best" and "boring" show judgment. Clue words like "best," "worst," and "boring" often signal opinion, while dates and counts can be checked.
2. A classmate says, "Anything I agree with is a fact." How would you correct this reasoning? Answer in 40-60 words.
Read the worked answer
Agreement is not evidence. A statement is a fact if it can be checked and proven, not because a reader likes it. Two people can agree on an opinion and still be wrong about it being a fact. The test is whether the statement can be verified, not whether it matches a reader's taste.