OBC General Legal practice questions

One question at a time. Build your OBC General Legal understanding.

First 50 of 200 questions. Each one lists the choices, the correct answer, and an explanation. The checker at the top of this page saves progress in this browser when it is available.

Continue in the practice tool above to load more questions, 50 at a time.

Question 1General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

Which body is responsible for making general rules for the practice of patent attorneys in Japan?

The Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry
The Fair Trade Commission
The Supreme Court
The Japan Patent Attorneys Association Correct answer.

Explanation

The Japan Patent Attorneys Association (Benrishi Kai) is the sole national association to which patent attorneys must belong, and it has authority to establish rules governing the practice and conduct of its members. These internal rules supplement statutory requirements and bind members directly.

Question 2General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

A person who has passed the patent attorney examination but has not yet completed the required practical training wishes to register. What is the consequence?

Registration may be refused because the training requirement is not satisfied Correct answer.
Registration is permitted with a provisional status for two years
Registration is permitted if a supervising attorney vouches for the person
Registration is permitted but practice is limited to drafting applications

Explanation

Registration as a patent attorney requires satisfaction of the statutory qualifications, which include completion of the practical training following examination. If the training requirement is not met, the registration may be refused. Passing the examination alone does not confer the right to register.

Question 3General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

Which of the following is a duty owed by a patent attorney to a client under the general legal framework?

To disclose the client's trade secrets to competitors for market fairness
To represent the client in criminal proceedings
To guarantee that a patent will be granted
To keep confidential information learned in the course of the engagement Correct answer.

Explanation

Patent attorneys owe a duty of confidentiality regarding information obtained in the course of their professional work, and this duty continues after the engagement ends. This protects client trust and is reinforced by professional discipline rules. A patent attorney cannot guarantee outcomes that depend on the patent office.

Question 4General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

A patent attorney is asked to represent a client in a civil lawsuit concerning infringement of a patent. Under the general framework, what is the correct position?

Patent attorneys may conduct litigation only if they also hold a lawyer's qualification or act under statutory authorization Correct answer.
Patent attorneys may conduct litigation only with special court permission for each case
Patent attorneys may always conduct litigation independently
Patent attorneys are prohibited from any involvement in infringement disputes

Explanation

Litigation representation is generally reserved to attorneys-at-law (bengoshi), and a patent attorney may appear in court only where the law specifically authorizes it, such as when also qualified as a lawyer or under particular statutory provisions. Patent attorneys may still assist clients with infringement matters outside formal court representation.

Question 5General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

Which statement best describes the nature of the patent attorney profession under the regulatory framework?

It is an unregulated commercial trade
It is a government agency function
It is a public-interest profession subject to state supervision Correct answer.
It is a purely private contract relationship with no oversight

Explanation

The patent attorney profession is treated as a public-interest profession, meaning practitioners serve the public interest while acting for clients and are subject to supervision and discipline. This status justifies mandatory membership in the association and statutory conduct obligations.

Question 6General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

A patent attorney discovers that a client intends to submit a document containing a knowingly false statement to the patent office. What is the most appropriate professional response?

Resign from the case without informing the client
Submit the document because the client bears sole responsibility
Submit the document but note the falsity in a separate letter
Refuse to assist with the false statement and advise the client of the legal risk Correct answer.

Explanation

A patent attorney must not participate in fraud or knowingly false submissions to the patent office, and should counsel the client against such conduct. The professional duty of candor and integrity prevails over client instructions to deceive. Withdrawal may follow if the client insists, but advising the client is the proper first step.

Question 7General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

Which entity grants registration to a successful applicant for patent attorney status?

The Japan Patent Attorneys Association
The Minister of Economy, Trade and Industry Correct answer.
The Commissioner of the Japan Patent Office
The National Personnel Authority

Explanation

Registration of patent attorneys is administered by the Minister of Economy, Trade and Industry, who maintains the register and may refuse or cancel registration on statutory grounds. The association maintains membership but is not the registering authority.

Question 8General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

A patent attorney wishes to establish a firm jointly with a certified public accountant. Which statement reflects the general framework for such collaboration?

Joint professional practice is permitted where the relevant statutes allow it Correct answer.
Joint practice is permitted only with lawyers
Joint practice requires approval from the patent office for each client
Joint practice with other professions is never permitted

Explanation

The framework permits patent attorneys to engage in joint professional practice with certain other qualified professions where the relevant statutes provide for it, such as through recognized professional corporation arrangements. The arrangement is governed by the applicable statutes rather than by case-by-case patent office approval.

Question 9General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

What is the primary purpose of the disciplinary system for patent attorneys?

To protect the public and maintain trust in the profession Correct answer.
To increase association revenue
To resolve fee disputes between clients and attorneys
To promote competition among firms

Explanation

Discipline exists to protect the public and preserve confidence in the profession by sanctioning misconduct. It is not a mechanism for resolving private fee disputes or raising revenue. Sanctions may range from admonition to cancellation of registration.

Question 10General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

A patent attorney has not paid the required annual membership fee to the association for several years. What is the most likely consequence under the regulatory framework?

Possible disciplinary measures for failure to fulfill membership obligations Correct answer.
Automatic cancellation of the patent attorney registration by the association
Transfer of the attorney's cases to the patent office
No consequence because fees are voluntary

Explanation

Membership in the association is mandatory and carries obligations including payment of fees. Persistent failure to meet these obligations can lead to disciplinary action, but the association does not itself cancel the registration granted by the Minister.

Question 11General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

Which of the following activities falls within the core scope of patent attorney practice?

Auditing a company's financial statements
Issuing judgments in civil litigation
Representing clients in patent and trademark application procedures before the patent office Correct answer.
Performing surgery in a hospital

Explanation

The core statutory function of a patent attorney is representation in proceedings relating to patents, utility models, designs, trademarks, and related matters before the Japan Patent Office. Other listed activities belong to distinct licensed professions.

Question 12General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

A client asks a patent attorney to handle a trademark opposition proceeding before the Japan Patent Office. Is this within the attorney's authority?

Only if the client is a foreign national
Yes, because trademark proceedings fall within the statutory scope of patent attorney practice Correct answer.
No, trademark matters are reserved to lawyers
Only if the attorney has a separate trademark license

Explanation

Patent attorneys are authorized to represent parties in trademark application and related proceedings before the Japan Patent Office, including oppositions and appeals. No separate trademark license exists beyond patent attorney registration.

Question 13General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

Which principle best explains why patent attorneys are prohibited from representing both parties to a dispute?

The association limits each attorney to one client per year
The patent office prohibits multiple clients per attorney
The duty of confidentiality and loyalty creates a conflict of interest Correct answer.
Fees cannot be divided between parties

Explanation

Representing opposing parties creates a conflict of interest that undermines the duties of loyalty and confidentiality owed to each client. The prohibition protects client trust and the integrity of the profession. It is not a numerical limit imposed by the patent office or association.

Question 14General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

A person who is not registered as a patent attorney advertises and performs patent application drafting services for compensation. What is the legal position?

This is permitted if the person has passed the examination
This may constitute unauthorized practice prohibited by law Correct answer.
This is permitted because drafting is a clerical service
This is permitted for foreign clients only

Explanation

Acting as a patent attorney for compensation without registration constitutes unauthorized practice, which the statute prohibits and may sanction. Passing the examination without registering does not authorize practice. The prohibition protects the public from unqualified representation.

Question 15General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

Which of the following best describes the relationship between the Japan Patent Attorneys Association and the government supervisor?

The association is a division of the Japan Patent Office
The association is entirely independent and free from any governmental oversight
The association sets the patent examination standards
The association operates under statutory authority and is subject to supervision by the Minister Correct answer.

Explanation

The association is established under statute and carries out self-governance functions such as membership and discipline, while remaining subject to supervision by the competent Minister. It is not a government division and does not set examination standards for patents.

Question 16General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

What is the effect of cancellation of a patent attorney's registration?

The person may continue practicing under a different title
The person may re-register immediately without any procedure
The person loses the legal capacity to act as a patent attorney Correct answer.
The person is automatically disbarred from all professions

Explanation

Cancellation of registration removes the person's legal authority to act as a patent attorney and to hold out as such. It does not affect qualifications for unrelated professions. Re-registration would require satisfying the statutory requirements again.

Question 17General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

Which statement about the continuing professional education of patent attorneys is accurate under the general framework?

Education is administered by the patent office for all attorneys
Education is entirely optional and has no professional significance
Education is mandated only for attorneys over sixty
The association promotes continuing education to maintain professional competence Correct answer.

Explanation

The association promotes continuing professional education as part of maintaining competence and public trust, though the framework emphasizes self-directed professional development. It is not administered by the patent office and is not age-based.

Question 18General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

A patent attorney is offered a success fee contingent on the grant of a patent. Which consideration is most relevant under the professional framework?

Fee arrangements must be approved by the patent office
Fee arrangements must not compromise the attorney's independent professional judgment Correct answer.
Success fees are permitted only for foreign clients
Contingency fees are prohibited in all professional engagements

Explanation

Fee arrangements are generally a matter of contract with the client, but they must not impair the attorney's independent judgment or create improper incentives. The framework focuses on preserving professional independence rather than banning contingency fees outright. Patent office approval of fees is not required.

Question 19General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

Which of the following is a ground on which registration as a patent attorney may be refused?

The applicant has a prior criminal conviction of a specified serious nature Correct answer.
The applicant has never worked in industry
The applicant resides outside the capital
The applicant is under thirty years of age

Explanation

The statute lists disqualifying grounds, which include certain criminal convictions and other specified circumstances that call into question fitness to practice. Age, prior industry experience, and place of residence are not disqualifying grounds.

Question 20General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

A patent attorney receives a request from a former client's opponent to handle a matter substantially related to the former engagement. What is the appropriate approach?

Accept the engagement and rely on memory of the former matter
Decline or seek informed consent because confidential information may be used against the former client Correct answer.
Accept the engagement because the former client relationship has ended
Accept only if the former client never paid the fees

Explanation

The duty of confidentiality continues after an engagement ends, and a substantially related matter creates a risk that the former client's information could be used against them. The attorney should decline or obtain informed consent where permitted. The end of the relationship does not extinguish the duty.

Question 21General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

Which of the following best characterizes the standard of conduct expected of a patent attorney in dealings with the patent office?

Deference to the client's instruction to conceal information
Silence about known material defects in an application
Honesty and candor in all submissions and communications Correct answer.
Zealous advocacy that permits misleading the examiner

Explanation

Patent attorneys must deal honestly and with candor toward the patent office, refraining from misleading submissions. Client instructions cannot justify concealment of material information. Zealous advocacy is bounded by these integrity obligations.

Question 22General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

What is the significance of the patent attorney register maintained by the Minister?

It provides public confirmation of who is authorized to practice Correct answer.
It ranks attorneys by success rate
It records patent applications filed each year
It lists only attorneys who have paid association fees

Explanation

The register is the official record of persons authorized to act as patent attorneys, allowing the public to confirm credentials. It is not a fee ledger, an application log, or a performance ranking.

Question 23General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

A patent attorney is asked to serve as an expert witness in a court proceeding concerning patent law. Is this permissible?

Only if the attorney is also a judge
Yes, patent attorneys may provide expert opinions where the court seeks specialized knowledge Correct answer.
Only with the consent of the opposing party
No, patent attorneys may never appear in court in any capacity

Explanation

Although patent attorneys cannot generally conduct litigation, they may serve as expert witnesses or provide specialized opinions when a court seeks their technical and legal expertise. This role is distinct from acting as counsel for a party.

Question 24General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

Which statement reflects the principle of professional independence for patent attorneys?

Attorneys must prioritize the largest fee offer
Attorneys should defer to the patent examiner's view in all cases
Attorneys must follow every client instruction without question
Attorneys should exercise independent judgment and advise clients objectively Correct answer.

Explanation

Professional independence means the attorney gives objective advice based on expertise rather than merely executing instructions or chasing fees. This supports the integrity of the professional relationship and the public interest. Deference to the examiner in all cases would undermine the duty to advocate for the client.

Question 25General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

Which of the following is true about the obligation of a patent attorney regarding client property and documents?

The attorney must handle client funds and documents with care and account for them Correct answer.
The attorney may destroy client files immediately after filing
The attorney may commingle client funds with personal funds freely
The attorney may retain client documents to secure unpaid fees without limit

Explanation

Patent attorneys must manage client money and documents with care, keep proper accounts, and return property on request subject to lawful liens. Commingling funds and arbitrary destruction of files are inconsistent with these duties.

Question 26General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

Under the Patent Attorneys Act, which body holds the power to grant a patent attorney's registration?

The Minister of Economy, Trade and Industry Correct answer.
The Supreme Court
The Japan Patent Attorneys Association
The Japan Patent Office

Explanation

Registration as a patent attorney is granted by the Minister of Economy, Trade and Industry, who maintains the patent attorney register. The Japan Patent Attorneys Association is a professional body that admits registered attorneys as members but does not itself confer registration. The Japan Patent Office handles patent procedures, not professional licensing.

Question 27General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

A registered patent attorney wishes to also practice as a lawyer (bengoshi). What does the framework generally require before the attorney may use the lawyer title?

Payment of an additional fee to the Japan Patent Office
Only a notification to the Japan Patent Attorneys Association
Nothing extra, because patent attorney status automatically includes lawyer status
Satisfaction of the qualifications required for admission to the bar Correct answer.

Explanation

Patent attorney registration and bar admission are separate qualifications, and holding one does not confer the other. A patent attorney who wishes to act as a lawyer must separately satisfy the qualifications for bar admission and complete that process. Mere notification or payment does not create lawyer status.

Question 28General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

A person who has been refused patent attorney registration believes the refusal was improper. Which avenue is most consistent with the general regulatory framework?

Requesting that the association conduct a disciplinary review
Filing an appeal against the refusal through the administrative remedy available under the Act Correct answer.
Petitioning the Japan Patent Office to override the decision
Directly filing a civil suit against the Japan Patent Attorneys Association

Explanation

Where registration is refused, the Act provides for an administrative appeal against that disposition, reflecting the general framework for challenging administrative decisions. The association is not the decision-maker on registration and cannot override it. A disciplinary review concerns conduct of already-registered attorneys, not a refusal to register.

Question 29General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

A patent attorney is engaged to draft and prosecute a patent application, and the client asks whether the attorney may also handle related court litigation as a lawyer. Which statement best reflects the general framework?

The attorney may litigate only if the client gives written consent
The attorney may litigate in court as a lawyer without any additional qualification
The attorney may litigate only if separately admitted as a lawyer Correct answer.
The attorney may litigate only with the permission of the Japan Patent Office

Explanation

Representation in court litigation is generally reserved to those admitted as lawyers, while patent attorney practice centers on patent and related procedures. A patent attorney therefore cannot undertake general court litigation solely by virtue of patent attorney registration. Client consent or office permission does not create lawyer status.

Question 30General Legal Principles and the Regulatory Framework

A registered patent attorney is convicted of a serious criminal offense unrelated to patent work. Which outcome is most consistent with the framework governing registration?

The attorney automatically loses only the right to appear before the Japan Patent Office
The registration is unaffected because the offense is unrelated to patent practice
The association may privately warn the attorney but cannot affect registration
The registration may be cancelled or refused on grounds tied to the attorney's fitness Correct answer.

Explanation

The Act ties registration to the attorney's fitness and provides grounds for refusal or cancellation of registration, including certain criminal convictions. Disqualification does not depend on whether the offense relates to patent work. The association's role is separate from the Minister's power over registration.

Question 31Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

Which element is required for a valid offer under general contract principles?

A written signature by both parties
A deposit paid by the offeree
A definite promise to be bound on stated terms Correct answer.
A notarized acknowledgment

Explanation

An offer must communicate a definite promise to be bound on terms that are sufficiently certain, so that acceptance creates a contract. Writing, notarization, and deposits are not generally required for an offer to exist.

Question 32Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

A company posts a notice: 'We will pay $100 to anyone who returns our lost parrot.' A neighbor returns the parrot. What type of contract has been formed?

A bilateral executory contract
A voidable contract
An implied-in-law contract
A unilateral contract Correct answer.

Explanation

A promise of payment for performance of a specified act is an offer for a unilateral contract, accepted by complete performance. The offeror is bound once the act is performed, without a return promise.

Question 33Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

Under the common law mirror image rule, an acceptance that adds new terms is generally what?

A conditional acceptance that still binds the offeror
A binding acceptance with the new terms included
A counteroffer Correct answer.
An option contract

Explanation

At common law, acceptance must match the offer exactly; a response that varies the terms operates as a rejection and a counteroffer. The original offer is thereby terminated.

Question 34Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

An offer states it will remain open for ten days, but the offeree gives no consideration for that promise. What is the effect?

The offer may be revoked before acceptance Correct answer.
The offer is irrevocable for ten days
The offer is firm under the UCC regardless of party status
The offer automatically becomes an option

Explanation

A promise to keep an offer open is generally unenforceable without consideration or a substitute such as a statutory firm offer or detrimental reliance. Absent that, the offeror may revoke before acceptance.

Question 35Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

Which acceptance is generally effective upon dispatch under the mailbox rule?

An acceptance by voicemail left after business hours
An acceptance mailed by the offeree to the offeror Correct answer.
An acceptance communicated by the offeror's agent to the offeree
An acceptance by email that the offeror never receives

Explanation

The mailbox rule makes a properly dispatched acceptance effective when sent, unless the offer specifies receipt. It applies to the offeree's dispatch of acceptance through an authorized medium.

Question 36Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

A contractor sends a homeowner a signed writing promising to hold a remodeling bid open for 30 days. The homeowner pays $500 for that promise. What has been created?

A firm offer under the UCC
A requirements contract
A voidable contract
An option contract Correct answer.

Explanation

Consideration paid to keep an offer open creates an option contract, making the offer irrevocable for the stated period. The UCC firm offer doctrine is unnecessary where consideration is given.

Question 37Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

Which circumstance most clearly terminates an offeree's power of acceptance?

The offeror mails a revocation that the offeree receives Correct answer.
The offeree begins preparing to accept
The offeree requests additional information
The offeror dies after the offeree accepts

Explanation

Revocation terminates the power of acceptance when it is actually received by the offeree, unless the offer was made irrevocable. Mere preparation or requests for information do not terminate the power.

Question 38Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

A buyer and seller agree on goods and quantity but leave the price open. Under the UCC, what is the result?

No contract because price is an essential term
A contract with a reasonable price at delivery Correct answer.
A contract only if a court later fixes the price
An unenforceable agreement to agree

Explanation

The UCC permits a sales contract to be formed even if the price is left open, with the price then being a reasonable price at the time of delivery. Quantity is the key term that must be certain.

Question 39Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

Which agreement is most likely unenforceable for indefiniteness?

A lease stating a rent amount and a one-year term
A sale of goods stating quantity and delivery date
An agreement to agree on all material terms later Correct answer.
An employment contract stating salary and duties

Explanation

An agreement that leaves all material terms to future negotiation lacks the certainty required for enforcement. Courts may fill gaps in some contracts, but they will not supply the entire bargain.

Question 40Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

A minor signs a contract to buy a car and later disaffirms while still a minor. What is the general effect?

The minor may avoid the contract and recover consideration Correct answer.
The minor must pay expectation damages
The contract is fully enforceable against the minor
The contract is void from the outset

Explanation

Contracts with minors are generally voidable at the minor's election, allowing disaffirmance and recovery of consideration, subject to restitution duties. They are not void ab initio.

Question 41Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

Which contract is most likely to be unenforceable because of illegality?

A contract to lease office space
A contract to sell lawful goods at a discount
A contract to commit a crime for payment Correct answer.
A contract to provide accounting services

Explanation

A bargain whose performance requires a criminal act is illegal and generally unenforceable. Courts will not aid a party in enforcing an agreement to break the law.

Question 42Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

A party signs a contract after the other party threatens to report a past crime unless the contract is signed. The threatened party later seeks to avoid the deal. What ground applies?

Commercial impracticability
Mutual mistake
Duress Correct answer.
Undue influence

Explanation

A threat to expose a past crime to obtain assent is improper pressure constituting duress, making the contract voidable. The threatened party may rescind.

Question 43Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

Both parties believe a shipment of goods is aboard a particular vessel, but it sank before the contract was signed. What doctrine likely allows avoidance?

Mutual mistake of fact Correct answer.
Unilateral mistake
Frustration of purpose
Anticipatory repudiation

Explanation

A shared mistaken belief about a basic factual assumption, such as the existence of the subject matter, permits avoidance of the contract. The mistake must be material and mutual.

Question 44Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

A party fails to read a written contract and later claims ignorance of a term. What is the general result?

The court rewrites the term in the party's favor
The party is bound unless fraud or unconscionability applies Correct answer.
The term is void for lack of assent
The contract is automatically rescinded

Explanation

A party who signs a contract is generally bound by its terms even without reading them, absent fraud, duress, or unconscionability. Courts do not rewrite terms merely because a party was careless.

Question 45Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

Which promise is generally enforceable without consideration under the doctrine of promissory estoppel?

A promise made without any expectation of reliance
A promise on which the promisee reasonably and detrimentally relied Correct answer.
A promise to pay a debt barred by limitation
A promise to make a gift if the promisee feels grateful

Explanation

Promissory estoppel enforces a promise when the promisor should reasonably expect reliance, reliance occurs, and injustice can be avoided only by enforcement. Detrimental, reasonable reliance substitutes for consideration.

Question 46Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

A party provides a service in response to a request without any discussion of payment. What type of contract may arise?

A contract implied in fact Correct answer.
A void contract
A quasi-contract implied in law
An express contract

Explanation

A contract implied in fact arises from conduct and circumstances showing mutual assent, such as requesting services under conditions implying payment. It is a real contract, unlike quasi-contract.

Question 47Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

A contract contains a material misrepresentation of fact on which the other party reasonably relies. What is the likely remedy?

The contract is automatically void
The contract is voidable by the innocent party Correct answer.
The misrepresenting party may rescind
The innocent party must perform and sue for damages only

Explanation

A material misrepresentation that induces assent makes the contract voidable at the election of the innocent party, who may rescind or sometimes seek damages. The contract is not void automatically.

Question 48Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

Which event constitutes anticipatory repudiation?

A party asks for assurance of the other side's performance
A party requests a change in the delivery schedule
A party clearly states before the due date that it will not perform Correct answer.
A party performs late without explanation

Explanation

Anticipatory repudiation occurs when a party unequivocally indicates before performance is due that it will not perform. The nonbreaching party may then treat the contract as breached.

Question 49Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

A party substantially performs a construction contract with only minor deviations. What is the nonbreaching party generally entitled to?

Complete rescission and restitution
Specific performance of the exact work
The contract price minus damages for the minor defects Correct answer.
Full contract price with no offset

Explanation

Substantial performance entitles the contractor to the contract price less damages for the minor, non-material defects. The owner may offset the cost of correcting those defects.

Question 50Contract Formation, Performance, and Remedies

Which circumstance may excuse performance under the doctrine of commercial impracticability?

A party experiences a temporary inconvenience
A party simply changes its business plans
An unforeseen event makes performance extremely and unreasonably difficult Correct answer.
A party finds performance more expensive than expected

Explanation

Impracticability requires an unforeseen event that makes performance extremely and unreasonably difficult, beyond mere increased cost or inconvenience. The risk must not have been allocated to the performing party.