The Broker Who Left: Supervision, Signature Authority, and a Branch Office
Alameda Trade Services, Inc. has held a national customs broker permit since 2015. On March 3 its only individually licensed broker, P. Okafor, resigned; the firm's designated corporate officer, D. Vance, has never held a license. Between March 4 and April 30, unlicensed entry writers at the firm's Newark office transmitted 212 entries, each carrying Okafor's electronic signature block, and the firm billed clients $48,000 for that work. In January the same firm opened a two-person office in Houston; no licensed broker is stationed there, although Okafor visited twice weekly until she left. CBP's regulatory auditor sent a records request on May 12. The firm's triennial status report, due February 1, was filed March 20.
1. Identify the Part 111 failures and analyze whether the 212 entries are legally void.
Read the worked answer
Failures
- No licensed broker behind the transmissions. A license and a national permit are prerequisites to conducting customs business for others (19 CFR 111.11, 111.19). After March 3 the firm had neither a licensed individual nor a qualifying officer; entry writers who are not licensed may perform only clerical or preparatory work, not the exercise of judgment on classification, value, or admissibility that constitutes customs business.
- Signature misuse. Transmitting an entry under a departed broker's signature block is a false representation of authority to CBP, independent of any duty-loss issue.
- Supervision. Each broker must exercise responsible supervision and control over the customs business it conducts, including at every office. Two unlicensed people in Houston with no on-site licensee, and a Newark operation with no licensee at all, fails that standard.
- Status report. The late triennial report is a separate, curable violation that supports discipline but does not by itself void anything.
Are the entries void?
No. Whether an entry is valid turns on CBP's acceptance of a proper entry by the importer of record, not on whether the filer was properly licensed. The importer remains liable for duties, and CBP will not treat the merchandise as unentered solely because the agent was unlicensed. That is cold comfort: the entries stand, the duties are owed, and the firm's misconduct is pursued separately under 19 U.S.C. 1641 and Part 111 discipline. The importer clients may also face 19 U.S.C. 1592 exposure for declarations the firm prepared.
2. What must the firm do before it may lawfully file another entry, and may it keep the Houston office open?
Read the worked answer
Restoring authority
- The firm must have a licensed broker in place - either hire an individually licensed broker to serve as its qualifying/responsible officer, or have a principal obtain a license (license by examination; a license is personal and cannot be purchased or borrowed).
- Until that happens, the firm may not transact customs business. Client files, POAs, and pending entries must be transferred to a licensed broker or returned to the client; entries transmitted by unlicensed staff must stop immediately.
- Notify CBP of the change in responsible broker and file the corrected status information; the late triennial report should be brought current and the reason documented.
Houston
A national permit authorizes customs business anywhere in the United States, so a separate local permit is not the obstacle. The obstacle is supervision. The firm must show that a licensed broker actually directs the Houston work: reviewing classifications and values, being reachable, controlling who may transmit, and auditing a sample of files. Whether twice-weekly visits suffice is a fact question - it depends on volume, complexity, and whether unlicensed staff make independent decisions. After Okafor's departure the Houston office had no supervision at all, which is the real defect.
3. What is the firm's exposure, and how should it respond to the May 12 records request?
Read the worked answer
Exposure
- 19 U.S.C. 1641 authorizes monetary penalties and suspension or revocation of the license and permit for misconduct, including a broker's participation in a negligent or fraudulent violation of the customs laws.
- If any of the 212 entries misstated classification or value, 19 U.S.C. 1592 exposure exists for both the importer and, potentially, the firm; the signature misuse may also support a false-statement theory.
- Private clients may sue for the consequences of using an unlicensed filer.
Responding
- Respond within the time stated in the request and produce the records. Brokers must retain entry records and POAs for five years; a claim that files are unavailable will be treated as an aggravating, not mitigating, fact.
- Preserve everything: transmission logs, the signature credentials, Houston staffing records, client correspondence.
- Do not volunteer conclusions about culpability in the production; keep the response factual.
- Consider, with counsel, a written self-report and a tender of any duty loss - that is the mechanism that converts a potential penalty case into a corrected one, and it should be evaluated before the auditor finishes.