Mid-Year State Aid Shortfall and Fund Balance Pressures
A school district adopts an annual budget on a cash basis. Six months into the fiscal year, state aid receipts are $4.2 million below budget because enrollment counts were revised downward. The district has $6.0 million in assigned fund balance and $1.1 million in unassigned fund balance. The board wants to transfer $3.0 million from the capital projects fund to cover operating costs and delay a $2.5 million textbook purchase. The charter requires a balanced budget and permits transfers only by board resolution. The district's CAFR presents budgetary comparison schedules using the original and final budget.
1. Identify and evaluate the district's options to close the $4.2 million state aid shortfall, including the proposed $3.0 million transfer and the textbook delay.
Read the worked answer
The district should first separate one-time from recurring causes. The $4.2 million shortfall is a revenue problem, not a spending problem, so using one-time balances or transfers may create a structural gap next year. The $1.1 million unassigned fund balance is the most flexible, but it covers only part of the gap. The $6.0 million assigned fund balance is not automatically available; the board must confirm the assignment's purpose and formally release it. The proposed $3.0 million transfer from the capital projects fund is risky: capital funds may be restricted by bond covenants, voter authorization, or law, and using them for operations can violate those restrictions and the charter's balanced-budget requirement. Delaying the $2.5 million textbook purchase may be possible, but the board must consider instructional mandates and whether the delay creates a future liability. Better options include reducing nonmandated spending, using a documented portion of assigned fund balance, seeking supplemental state aid, and phasing purchases. Any transfer requires a board resolution and legal review.
2. Explain how the district should amend and present its budget and what the budgetary comparison schedule should show.
Read the worked answer
The board should adopt a formal budget amendment by resolution that reduces state aid revenue and adjusts appropriations, other financing sources, or fund balance use so the final budget balances. Because transfers require board action, the resolution should document the legal authority and any restrictions on the capital projects fund. The budgetary comparison schedule in the CAFR should present the original budget, the final amended budget, and actual amounts on the budgetary basis, with variances. Because the budget is prepared on a cash basis, the district should include a reconciliation to GAAP if the schedule is presented with the basic financial statements. It should disclose the basis of budgeting, the nature of amendments, and any excess of expenditures over appropriations. If fund balance is used, the schedule should show it consistently with the budget basis, and the district should explain in management's discussion and analysis how it will avoid relying on one-time resources in the future.