Lakeshore Urgent Care: Choosing a Primary Target
Lakeshore Urgent Care operates six clinics in a metro area of 900,000 people. Average visit revenue is $145; fixed costs per clinic are $1.1 million annually. It currently markets to everyone with the tagline 'Walk in when you need us.' Volumes are flat, and wait times average 52 minutes, hurting satisfaction. Three segments appear. Segment A is 210,000 residents aged 18–44 with high-deductible plans; they use urgent care about 1.1 times per year and choose on price and online booking. Segment B is 95,000 Medicare-eligible seniors; they visit about 2.3 times per year but have complex needs and lower reimbursement. Segment C is 1,400 small employers needing occupational health and pre-employment screenings, averaging $38,000 in annual contract value. Lakeshore has no occupational health salesforce and only one clinic near the industrial park. Management must choose a primary target for the next 18 months.
1. Evaluate the three segments against the five criteria for effective segmentation: measurable, substantial, accessible, differentiable, and actionable. Use the case numbers where possible.
Read the worked answer
Segment A: 210,000 residents times 1.1 visits gives about 231,000 visits, or roughly $33.5 million in visit revenue potential. It is measurable through claims and geo-data, accessible through digital and search, substantial, and differentiable through online booking and published prices. It is actionable with the existing clinic model, though the 52-minute wait undermines the promise. Segment B: 95,000 times 2.3 gives about 218,500 visits, or $31.7 million gross, but Medicare reimbursement is lower and complex needs require care coordination. It is measurable and substantial, but less accessible without primary-care referral relationships and less aligned with current operations. Segment C: 1,400 employers times $38,000 gives $53.2 million in contract value, clearly substantial and differentiable through employer service and compliance. However, it is not very actionable because Lakeshore lacks a salesforce and has only one suitable clinic. Overall, A is the strongest fit on accessibility and operational capability; C is attractive but capability-constrained; B is a served market rather than a growth target.
2. Recommend a primary target and write a positioning statement. Then explain what service operations must change for that positioning to be credible.
Read the worked answer
Primary target: Segment A, working adults aged 18–44 with high-deductible plans. Secondary pilot: Segment C, limited to a small number of employers near the industrial-park clinic. Positioning statement: For working adults in the metro who have high-deductible plans and want care without a long wait, Lakeshore Urgent Care is the urgent-care chain that lets you reserve a visit online, see the price before you arrive, and be seen within a 20-minute target, because it schedules and staffs to demand rather than accepting uncontrolled walk-in queues. Operations must change before marketing makes this claim: deploy online scheduling with reserved slots, publish self-pay and insurer prices, manage staffing by hour and day, and track door-to-clinician time. Marketing a promise the clinics cannot keep would worsen satisfaction. The 52-minute average is an operational constraint, not a message problem.
3. Should Lakeshore stop serving the other two segments? Explain the risks of both abandoning and continuing to market to everyone.
Read the worked answer
It should not abandon them. Segment B uses capacity and supports referral relationships, and Segment C has high contract value even without a dedicated salesforce. The risk of continuing to market to everyone is message dilution: a generic 'walk in' message supports neither the online-reservation promise for A nor the employer-service promise for C. The risk of abandoning B is lost volume and community reputation; the risk of abandoning C is forgoing a high-value segment that could be piloted. The correct choice is to concentrate marketing on A, serve B as a maintained segment, and pursue C selectively through one clinic and a limited employer pilot. Segmentation does not require refusing customers outside the target; it requires aligning spending and operations with the chosen target.