The Counterfeit Medicine Contract
A 24-year-old Christian trader, Ngozi, in Bamenda Main Market receives an offer from a wholesaler to distribute a batch of antimalarial tablets at 40% below market price. The wholesaler hints the tablets are 're-labelled' but says no one will know. Profit would be 3,000,000 FCFA in two months, enough to pay her mother's hospital bills and her younger brother's school fees. Her mother is ill with malaria. Her pastor preaches that Christians must be honest but also that family provision is a duty. A rival trader was recently arrested for selling fake drugs; two children in her neighbourhood died after taking counterfeit syrup. Ngozi must decide by Friday. Her church cell group is divided: one member says 'God helps those who help themselves'; another quotes 'You shall not steal.' She asks you for guidance.
1. Identify the moral issues and the biblical principles from the Ten Commandments and the Sermon on the Mount that bear on Ngozi's decision. Explain how each principle applies.
Read the worked answer
Moral issue: Ngozi is being asked to profit from medicine that may be fake, endangering patients. The key facts are the 40% price cut, the hint of 're-labelling', the 3,000,000 FCFA profit, her mother's malaria, and the recent arrest and child deaths.
Ten Commandments:
- You shall not steal (Ex 20:15): Selling counterfeit drugs takes money by deception; the buyer does not receive what is paid for.
- You shall not murder (Ex 20:13): Knowingly distributing fake antimalarials can kill, so accepting the contract shows reckless disregard for life.
- You shall not bear false witness (Ex 20:16): The re-labelling is a lie about the product's identity and safety.
Sermon on the Mount:
- Golden Rule (Matt 7:12): Ngozi would not want fake medicine given to her mother; she must treat buyers as she would want to be treated.
- Salt and light (Matt 5:13–16): Her business practices are public testimony; dishonest gain damages Christian witness.
- Treasure in heaven (Matt 6:19–21): The profit is temporary and corruptible; integrity is eternal.
- Do not worry (Matt 6:25–34): Family need is real, but Jesus calls disciples to trust God's provision rather than secure it through wrongdoing.
Reasoning: The principles converge: accepting the contract violates love of neighbour and truth. The duty to provide for family is genuine but cannot override the duty not to harm others.
2. Evaluate three possible courses of action (accept, refuse silently, refuse and report) using a Christian moral decision-making framework. Which is most defensible?
Read the worked answer
Framework: Christian moral decision-making involves (1) gathering facts, (2) identifying biblical principles, (3) imagining consequences for neighbours, (4) considering the virtues and witness involved, (5) seeking counsel, and (6) deciding.
Option A - Accept. Short-term gain pays bills, but it breaks the commandments against stealing, murder and false witness; it exposes children to death; it scandalises the church and risks arrest. Consequences for neighbours are severe. Not defensible.
Option B - Refuse silently. This avoids personal guilt but leaves the counterfeit batch in circulation. It fails the command to love your neighbour (Lev 19:18; Matt 22:39) and the civic duty to protect the public (Rom 13:1–4). It may also leave Ngozi vulnerable to pressure. Weakly defensible.
Option C - Refuse and report. This upholds truth, protects patients, and accepts short-term loss for the sake of the common good. It risks retaliation, so it needs wisdom: document the offer, report to the health authority or police, and ask her pastor for support. It is the most defensible because it honours both love of God and love of neighbour.
3. How should Ngozi's church community support her if she refuses the contract, and what does this show about Christian living in society?
Read the worked answer
Support: The church should not leave Ngozi alone. Practical steps could include a discreet emergency fund for her mother's treatment, help accessing legitimate work, prayer and pastoral encouragement, and legal or advocacy support if the wholesaler threatens her. The cell group should stop repeating slogans like 'God helps those who help themselves' as a justification for sin and instead study the Sermon on the Mount together.
What it shows: Christian living in society is corporate, not merely individual. The church is the body of Christ (1 Cor 12:26), so when one member suffers loss for righteousness, others share the cost. This also models social responsibility: protecting public health and reporting crime are acts of citizenship and stewardship. Ngozi's refusal then becomes a public witness that honesty matters more than profit, while the church's support shows that integrity need not mean destitution.