Warehouse Lease Commencement and Modification
On 1 January 20X5, Harbor Logistics enters a five-year lease for a warehouse. Annual fixed payments are $120,000, payable in advance each 1 January. Harbor also pays variable payments of $8 per pallet handled above 10,000 pallets per year, and it pays property taxes of $15,000 per year directly to the taxing authority. The lease requires a $50,000 refundable security deposit. Harbor incurs $20,000 of initial direct costs. The rate implicit in the lease is not readily determinable, and Harbor's incremental borrowing rate is 6%. The lease contains no renewal or purchase option, and ownership does not transfer. On 31 December 20X6, Harbor and the lessor amend the lease to extend the term by two years and reduce the annual fixed payment to $110,000 for all remaining years; the modification does not grant an additional right of use that is separately priced. Harbor had no indicators of impairment before or after the modification.
1. Measure the lease liability and right-of-use asset at commencement. Which payments are included, and how are the variable payments, property taxes, and security deposit treated?
Read the worked answer
The lease term is five years. Include the fixed payments of $120,000 because they are unavoidable and payable in advance. Exclude the variable payments of $8 per pallet above 10,000 pallets; they are based on usage, not an index or rate, and are expensed when incurred. Exclude the property taxes because Harbor pays them directly to the taxing authority; they are not lease payments. Exclude the refundable $50,000 security deposit; it is a financial asset, not consideration for the right to use the warehouse.
The lease liability is the present value of five $120,000 payments in advance at 6%. Using an annuity-due factor of 4.46511: $120,000 × 4.46511 = $535,813. The right-of-use asset is the liability plus initial direct costs: $535,813 + $20,000 = $555,813.
Initial entry: debit right-of-use asset $555,813; credit lease liability $535,813; credit cash $20,000. The security deposit is recorded as a receivable. Variable payments and property taxes are expensed as incurred.
2. Prepare the modification analysis at 31 December 20X6. Is this a separate lease? How are the liability and ROU asset adjusted?
Read the worked answer
The modification is not a separate lease because it does not grant an additional right of use at a price commensurate with its standalone price; it changes the term and consideration of the existing lease. Remeasure the lease liability using the revised terms and the current incremental borrowing rate, assumed unchanged at 6%.
Liability immediately before modification: initial $535,813; after the 1 January 20X5 payment, $415,813; add 6% interest of $24,949, $440,762; after the 1 January 20X6 payment, $320,762; add 6% interest of $19,246, $340,008. Thus the pre-modification liability is approximately $340,008.
Revised payments are five payments of $110,000 in advance (three remaining original years plus two extension years). Present value = $110,000 × 4.46511 = $491,162. The liability increases by $151,154.
Because the modification does not reduce the scope of the right to use, adjust the ROU asset by the same increase. ROU carrying amount before modification: $555,813 - (2/5 × $555,813) = $333,488. New ROU asset = $333,488 + $151,154 = $484,642. Future depreciation is over the remaining five years. No gain or loss is recognized because the liability increased. If the revised liability had been lower, the ROU asset would be reduced first, with any excess recognized as a gain.
3. How would the answer change if Harbor had elected the short-term lease exemption? Discuss whether it is available.
Read the worked answer
The short-term lease exemption is available only if the lease term at commencement is 12 months or less and does not include a purchase option. Harbor's lease term is five years, so the exemption is not available at commencement. The later extension does not create eligibility because eligibility is assessed at commencement. Harbor also cannot use the low-value asset exemption because a warehouse is not a low-value asset.
If the exemption had been available, Harbor would not recognize a lease liability or ROU asset. It would expense the fixed payments on a straight-line basis over the lease term, or another systematic basis if more representative. Variable payments and property taxes would still be expensed as incurred, and the security deposit would still be a receivable. The modification would not require remeasuring a lease liability because none would exist.