Resolving a Crowded Courtyard Poster: Tangents, Equal Spacing and a Fixed Text Block
A design paper asks for an A2 poster (420 × 594 mm) built from a supplied photograph of a school courtyard, using two colours plus black and white. Four constraints are non-negotiable: the plane tree must be included, the doorway must be included, at least two figures must appear, and an unaltered text block 80 mm high by 200 mm wide must be placed somewhere in the layout. The candidate's first layout has the horizon on the exact vertical centre; the tree trunk stands 3 mm clear of the doorway's vertical edge; the two figures are spaced equidistantly from each other and from the page edges; and the text block sits over the densest part of the foliage. The tutor's only comment was that the poster 'has no entry point'.
1. The candidate must now decide the dominant element and the value structure. Set out the reasoning and a concrete plan.
Read the worked answer
The dominant element should be the plane tree, for reasons of scale and of the constraints: it is the largest single shape available, it can function as a silhouette against sky, and it is the element the format can be organised around. The figures then become the secondary accents and the doorway the tertiary detail that confirms scale.
The value structure should be planned as a notan - a three-value study no larger than a postcard - before anything is redrawn, because a two-colour-plus-black-and-white brief lives or dies on shape阅读. The plan:
- Black (largest dark): the tree's mass, simplified into one connected silhouette, with the trunk joined to the crown so it reads as a single shape rather than a lollipop.
- White (largest light): the sky or the courtyard ground, allocated as one uninterrupted area that touches two edges - this is the quiet space the text can later occupy.
- Colour one: the doorway, kept as a clean rectangle of colour so it reads as architecture, not texture.
- Colour two: the two figures, in flat shapes, placed on the boundary between black and white so each figure is partly light-on-dark and partly dark-on-light - the strongest possible attention device with only two colours.
A crop decision should follow: cropping into the tree so the crown runs off the top edge and the trunk is off-centre gives the poster a scale larger than the page, and removes the need to fit the whole tree into the format.
2. Where should the 80 × 200 mm text block go, and how should it be integrated?
Read the worked answer
The block must not be treated as a label stuck onto a finished picture; it is a shape with a value and a weight, and it has to be placed as part of the notan.
The reasoning runs in three steps. First, the block's proportions are fixed at 1:2.5 and its area is significant relative to A2, so it will occupy roughly a sixth of the width - too large to hide. Second, it cannot sit over the tree's texture (illegible) or over the focal figure (it would decapitate the entry point). Third, it should sit in the quiet area already reserved for it, which after the notan plan is the sky or the ground.
The best placement is therefore in the upper or lower corner opposite the figures, aligned to one of the page's margins rather than floated: a block aligned to the left margin and the top margin reads as structure; a block centred in open space reads as a stamp. If the block lands on a single value - all white or all black - it needs no frame and should simply be set in the contrasting colour. If it must cross a value boundary, the boundary should cross it at one point only, ideally at a horizontal, and never pass diagonally behind the type.
One further move strengthens the integration: let an element of the image align to the block. Aligning the top of the text block with the doorway's lintel, or the block's left edge with the trunk, makes the block look designed into the space rather than applied to it - and the alignment costs nothing.