Four at the Door, One Line, 11:47 p.m.
You are the door person at a 180-seat tavern in Shaw on a Saturday. It is 11:47 p.m., the license allows service until 2:00 a.m., the line is forty deep, and the ABC Manager is on the floor. Four people reach you together, say they are one party on one tab, and are celebrating a birthday.
Person A hands you an unexpired Virginia driver's license in the vertical, under-21 format; the date of birth makes them 21 years and 3 months old. Person B hands you a DC driver's license that expired three weeks ago plus a paper DMV renewal notice with their name printed on it. Person C holds up a phone showing a photo of their passport photo page and says the actual passport is in a hotel safe. Person D hands you a university student ID with a photo, name, and date of birth printed on it.
Person A says, 'We're all 21, just scan us and let's go.' The line behind them is getting loud and the patio is already full.
1. For each of the four people, decide whether you may accept the document as proof of age, and explain the reasoning.
Read the worked answer
| Person | Accept? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A | Yes | The vertical layout only signals that the license was first issued to someone under 21. It is still unexpired, government-issued, and carries a date of birth you can compute yourself: 21 years and 3 months. Compare the photo, do the math, check the laminate and fonts, then accept. You always retain the right to refuse for any non-discriminatory reason. |
| B | No | An expired credential is not valid identification, and a DMV renewal notice is a piece of paper, not a photo ID. Nothing on the accepted list covers an expired license. |
| C | No | A photo on a phone is not a document. It can be edited in seconds and tells you nothing about who is holding the phone. The physical passport, presented in person, would be acceptable. |
| D | No | A university ID is not government-issued proof of age; student cards are easy to fake and are not on the accepted list. |
The accepted forms are current driver's licenses and ID cards from DC, a US state or territory, US and foreign passports, and military IDs. Current is part of the definition.
2. Person A is angry and says you are carding the whole group because of one person. How do you handle the party without escalating, and what happens to B, C, and D?
Read the worked answer
Step out of the doorway first. The queue is the audience, and an argument in front of forty people gets louder, not quieter.
Say it once, quietly, to Person A: 'I can't accept three of these, so I can't let the group in tonight.' Do not narrate B's, C's, and D's documents to the line, and do not hand a document back with commentary that announces 'fake' to everyone behind them.
Then offer real options instead of a flat no. B can return with a current license or a passport. C can return with the passport. D cannot come in tonight. A is an adult and may enter alone, but say plainly that if A is seen passing drinks to D at the rail or on the patio, A's tab gets closed and the group leaves.
Do not hold anyone's ID. If they keep pushing, the door person calls the ABC Manager and the manager makes the final decision. Log the refusal: time, description, reason, who handled it. A short note taken at 11:50 p.m. is worth more than a reconstruction two weeks later.
3. At 1:35 a.m. you see Person A on the patio hand a beer through the railing to Person D, who is standing on the sidewalk. What is the violation, and what do you do?
Read the worked answer
Furnishing alcohol to a person under 21 is a violation whether or not money changes hands, and once that bottle crosses the rail, the licensee is exposed, not just Person A. The sale to A was lawful; the transfer was not, and your premises are where it started.
Order of operations: take the bottle, tell A the tab is closed, and tell D to leave the property. Do not grab anyone. If either refuses, the ABC Manager calls MPD.
Write it up the same night: time, who served A, what A bought, who received it, who intervened, whether MPD was called. Keep the POS record and preserve patio camera footage. ABCA can request video, and a contemporaneous log supports the establishment far better than a story assembled later.
Then fix the process that allowed it: one person buying for a group with no per-drink control, patio seating against a public sidewalk with no barrier or rail-height rule, and nobody assigned to watch that rail during the last hour.