Evacuating Kharkov's Tank Industry, August 1941
You are the deputy people's commissar for the tank industry in August 1941. German armored spearheads are 200 kilometers from Kharkov, home of the Kharkov Tractor Works and a major tank design bureau. You have ten days and 2,200 railway wagons. The plant holds 15,000 workers, 3,000 machine tools, 400 unfinished T-34 hulls, and stocks of specialty steel. Front commanders demand every finished tank immediately; Moscow demands that the design bureau and machine tools reach the Urals intact. Evacuation of all workers and equipment would require 3,000 wagons and two weeks. Rail lines are already congested with troop trains. A wrong priority could either weaken the immediate defense of Kharkov or cripple future tank production. You must recommend what loads first, what is destroyed, and who stays behind. The local party committee reports that 4,000 workers have already been pressed into militia units.
1. Rank the evacuation priorities. Justify your ranking using the concepts of immediate combat power, industrial reconstitution, and irreplaceable human capital.
Read the worked answer
Priority: first the design bureau, blueprints, and specialist engineers; second critical machine tools, especially gear-cutting and engine tools; third skilled workers; fourth finished tanks, which should be driven or railed to the front if possible; fifth raw steel, which is bulky and replaceable, destroyed if left. Rationale: finished tanks have immediate combat value but are expendable; machine tools and design knowledge are irreplaceable and determine future production. The 2,200 wagons cannot carry 3,000 tools plus 15,000 workers, so the choice must protect reconstitution. Human capital matters, but not all workers are equally scarce; prioritize engineers and toolmakers. This is a judgement about time: if the enemy arrives in ten days, loading must begin with the highest-value, lightest items. The ranking accepts short-term combat risk to protect the Soviet Union's ability to replace losses in 1942.
2. What information would change your priority order?
Read the worked answer
Change if rail cut within 48 hours: load people first, because machinery without operators is useless and workers can be reassembled elsewhere. Change if the front can hold and rail remains open: machinery first, because finished tanks can be used locally. Change if specialty steel cannot be replaced in the Urals: load it before general tools, because the Urals may lack alloy inputs. Change if finished tanks can be armed and crewed locally: send them to the front rather than evacuate them, freeing wagons for tools. The key variables are time to rail interdiction, local combat need, and substitutability of inputs. A deputy commissar should set triggers in advance so loading crews do not improvise under fire.
3. How should you decide what to destroy, and what are the consequences of destroying too much or too little?
Read the worked answer
Destroy anything that directly aids the enemy: power plants, fuel depots, bridges, steel stock, and tools too heavy to move. Do not destroy housing, food, or water works unless militarily necessary, because those resources also sustain civilians and returning workers. Too much destruction cripples postwar recovery and civilian morale; too little gives the enemy industrial capacity and transport. The standard should be military utility to the enemy, not punitive destruction. Destruction must be sequenced with evacuation: blow up what cannot be loaded only after the last train leaves, or the blast damages the rail yard needed for departure. A written list with local commanders prevents both unauthorized demolition and premature demolition. The judgement is that scorched earth is a tactical tool, not a total policy.