Reasonable Compensation vs. Distributions for an S Corporation Owner
Devon is the sole shareholder-employee of an S corporation providing IT consulting. In 2025 the corporation earned net profit of $180,000 before any payments to Devon. Devon took no salary and instead took $150,000 in distributions, reporting the remainder as pass-through income. The corporation has no other employees. Comparable IT consultants in the area earn salaries of $90,000–$110,000. Devon argues that because he is the only owner, he can characterize all payments as distributions to avoid payroll taxes. The corporation's prior-year return reported no wages.
1. Is Devon's no-salary position sustainable, and what standard applies?
Read the worked answer
No. An S corporation shareholder-employee who performs services must receive reasonable compensation as wages before distributions. The IRS and courts apply a facts-and-circumstances standard (revenue rulings and case law such as Watson and Radtke): the value of services, comparable salaries, training, duties, and time devoted. Devon's active full-time consulting role with $180,000 of profit and comparable salaries of $90,000–$110,000 strongly supports a reasonable wage in that range. Treating all payments as distributions is a recharacterization risk; the IRS can reclassify distributions as wages, assess employment taxes, and impose penalties. The absence of other employees does not exempt the owner.
2. If the IRS recharacterizes $100,000 of distributions as wages, what are the payroll tax and income tax consequences?
Read the worked answer
Reclassification reduces the S corporation's ordinary income by the $100,000 wage (so pass-through income falls), but the corporation owes employer FICA (6.2% Social Security up to the wage base plus 1.45% Medicare) and must withhold the employee share (6.2% + 1.45%), plus FUTA. Devon's W-2 wages increase, and his distributive share decreases correspondingly-so his total income tax may be similar, but payroll taxes are now due. The corporation may also face penalties and interest for failure to file Forms 941/W-2 and deposit taxes. The distribution portion remains a tax-free return of basis to the extent of stock basis. The net effect: additional ~15.3% payroll tax on the reclassified amount (split employer/employee), plus penalties-making the no-salary strategy economically inferior.