EASA090 aviation-communications foundations study materials
EASA090 aviation-communications foundations study resources

A readback preserves the clearance

EASA090 aviation-communications foundations · Put your knowledge to work in context.

All case studies

A readback preserves the clearance

A fictional classroom recording contains an addressed instruction to climb to flight level one two zero. The learner's readback instead states flight level one three zero. The controller hears this discrepancy before the aircraft acts. One observer says the readback has now amended the clearance automatically; another proposes saying ROGER and leaving the two different values unresolved. The task asks how the communication loop should be repaired. It does not supply a real route, aircraft performance or permission for any actual climb. Both values are included only to make the mismatch explicit. A complete answer distinguishes the instruction as issued from the incorrectly repeated value and explains the need for a corrected message and accurate readback, using the intended aircraft identity so another station's instruction cannot be confused with it.

1. Has the readback automatically changed the clearance?

Read the worked answer

No. Repeating a different value does not itself amend the issued clearance. The discrepancy must be corrected and the actual instruction accurately read back.

2. Why is ROGER insufficient here?

Read the worked answer

It acknowledges receipt without resolving which level was understood. The required safety-related numerical readback must preserve the actual clearance.