Transitional duty after shoulder surgery
Elena, a 38-year-old warehouse associate, is 11 weeks post rotator cuff repair from a work-related injury. Her treating physician releases her for four hours per day with a 10-pound lifting limit, no overhead reaching, and no repetitive pushing. Her regular order-picking job requires lifting up to 35 pounds, overhead stocking, and eight-hour shifts. The workers' compensation insurer accepts the claim and pays temporary total disability. The employer offers a temporary tool-room assignment: 20 hours per week at the employee's pre-injury base rate, but the tool room requires lifting 20-pound tool cases onto shelves above shoulder height. Elena refuses, saying the offer is not within her restrictions and that she wants to stay home until she is 100% healed. Her supervisor is pressuring the case manager to close the claim and mark her as noncompliant.
1. Should the case manager endorse the tool-room offer? Explain the analysis.
Read the worked answer
The case manager should not endorse the tool-room assignment as offered. A transitional-duty offer is useful only if it is consistent with the treating physician's restrictions and with objective job demands. The tool room requires lifting 20-pound cases above shoulder height, which conflicts with the 10-pound limit and no-overhead-reaching restriction. Endorsing it would set Elena up to fail and could undermine the workers' compensation and ADA processes. Instead, obtain a written job analysis of the tool-room tasks, including shelf height, frequency, and push/pull forces, and send it to the physician for a fit-for-duty opinion. If the job can be modified with lower shelves, team lifts, a lift table, or a different task, reassess. A bona fide offer should be in writing, describe the physical demands, pay, and duration, and give the physician a chance to approve. Pressure to close the claim is not a clinical reason to approve an unsafe job match.
2. What are the next steps to identify suitable transitional work and address wage concerns?
Read the worked answer
Build a short list of tasks that fit the current restrictions: seated inspection, small-parts kitting, inventory data entry, or tool-room work only if modified. Confirm each task's physical demands with a job analysis rather than a title. Ask the physician whether four hours per day is a firm limit and when it should be reassessed. Coordinate with the workers' compensation adjuster on how partial-day work affects temporary total disability benefits in that jurisdiction; a transitional assignment may reduce or supplement wage-loss benefits depending on state rules. The employer should not promise that a lower-hour assignment preserves full pay unless that is the actual policy. Give Elena the written offer, the physician's approval, and a clear explanation of pay and benefits. If she refuses a genuinely suitable offer, document the reasons and the possible effect on benefits, but do not threaten retaliation.
3. How should the supervisor's pressure and Elena's refusal be documented and managed?
Read the worked answer
The supervisor's pressure should be redirected into objective case management. Remind the supervisor that the employer must engage in the interactive process and that a refusal of an unsafe or unsuitable offer is not automatically noncompliance. Document the dates of the offer, the physical requirements, the physician's restrictions, and the specific reason the offer did not match. Ask Elena to explain her refusal in writing and offer to send the job analysis to her physician. If she simply wants to stay home until 100% healed, explain that temporary transitional work may be expected when it is safe and available, and that benefits are governed by the workers' compensation statute. Continue to search for suitable work and set a review date. Avoid labeling her noncompliant before the medical fit question is resolved.