Extended leave and phased return during cancer treatment
Sophia, a 41-year-old customer service representative, was diagnosed with breast cancer and is undergoing chemotherapy. She has exhausted her 12 weeks of FMLA leave and requests an additional eight weeks off. Her oncologist expects her to be able to return part-time after that, with fatigue-related limits: no more than four hours per day initially, two additional rest breaks per shift, and reduced screen time because of neuropathy. Her job is answering phone calls eight hours per day with scheduled breaks. The employer has 75 employees and a policy terminating employees after FMLA exhaustion unless they can return to full duty. Sophia has no paid leave left and asks whether she will lose health insurance. The case manager is asked to advise HR on the leave request and possible return-to-work plan.
1. Is the employer required to grant the additional eight weeks? Explain the ADA and leave analysis.
Read the worked answer
Assuming the employer is covered by the ADA and FMLA, the additional eight weeks is not automatically required, but it cannot be denied solely because the 12-week FMLA entitlement is exhausted. The ADA may require additional leave as a reasonable accommodation when it is likely to enable the employee to return to work and does not impose undue hardship. The employer should engage in the interactive process, obtain updated information from the oncologist about the expected return date and restrictions, and consider the length of the leave, whether the position can be held open, and whether temporary coverage is available. A policy of automatic termination at FMLA exhaustion is risky. The employer should document its analysis and consider alternatives such as a temporary transfer, part-time return, or a further short leave.
2. How should the case manager plan the part-time return with restrictions?
Read the worked answer
Plan the return around the oncologist's restrictions and the actual job demands. The customer service role requires prolonged sitting, screen use, and continuous phone work; ask whether four hours per day, additional rest breaks, and a reduced call queue are medically appropriate. Consider a phased schedule, temporary part-time status, assistive technology, and a quiet space for breaks. Confirm whether the employer can temporarily modify the schedule without displacing other employees. Put the plan in writing, with start date, hours, restrictions, review dates, and the person responsible for updates. Coordinate with the supervisor so the team understands only the necessary restrictions. If the employee cannot perform essential functions even with accommodation, consider reassignment to a vacant position before ending employment.
3. What should HR do about the policy and Sophia's health insurance concerns?
Read the worked answer
HR should revise the approach to the written policy: it can state a general expectation, but it should not override the individualized ADA analysis. The case manager should ask HR to suspend any automatic termination decision, review Sophia's leave and accommodation request, and document the undue-hardship factors if the leave cannot be granted. On health insurance, determine whether FMLA continuation, COBRA, or an employer policy applies; do not tell Sophia she will lose coverage without checking the plan documents and applicable law. Keep communication respectful and provide a single point of contact. If the employer ultimately denies the additional leave, give a written explanation and consider a shorter leave, part-time return, or reassignment as alternatives.