The Deposit That Sat in the Operating Account
Dana is a newly licensed sales associate at Gulfstream Realty. On Saturday, January 11, she writes an offer for buyer Marcus and accepts his $15,000 personal check made payable to Gulfstream Realty. The contract is ratified Sunday. Dana's broker, Ms. Okafor, is out of the country until Thursday and left no instructions. On Monday, wanting to keep the check 'somewhere safe,' Dana deposits it into the brokerage's general operating account and writes a $900 check from that same account for yard signs. On Wednesday the deal collapses over a failed inspection, and Marcus demands his $15,000 back. The operating account balance is $1,140. Dana's unlicensed assistant, Ray, had earlier called Marcus to say the seller 'would probably kick in $3,000 toward closing costs.'
1. Identify every escrow and licensing violation in this scenario. When and where should the money have gone?
Read the worked answer
Three problems, and they compound:
- Delivery and deposit timing. Under FREC Rule 61J2-14.008 a sales associate must deliver trust funds to the broker promptly, and the broker must deposit them into an escrow (trust) account by the end of the third business day after receipt. A weekend receipt and an absent broker do not extend the deadline, and the broker's absence is not an excuse; the broker must have a procedure in place.
- Commingling. Placing buyer funds in the brokerage's general operating account, and writing business expenses from that account while buyer money sits in it, is commingling, which is prohibited regardless of intent.
- Conversion. Because $900 of the deposit was spent, the account cannot cover $15,000. Using escrow money for the broker's own purposes is conversion, the most serious escrow violation.
The funds should have been held in the broker's escrow account (or delivered to a title company or attorney escrow under the contract), untouched, until closing or a lawful disbursement.
2. Marcus wants his money on Wednesday. Who is responsible for returning it if the account is short, and what happens if the seller also claims the deposit?
Read the worked answer
The escrow obligation runs to the broker. Gulfstream Realty owes Marcus the full $15,000 even though Dana made the mistake; a shortfall must be made whole immediately from the broker's personal or business funds. The broker cannot say 'the associate had the check.'
If buyer and seller both claim the money, the escrow agent does not pick a winner. It holds the funds until (a) both parties sign a written release, (b) the contract's mediation/arbitration process produces a decision, or (c) a court orders disbursement, or the escrow agent interpleads the funds. Holding in good faith is not a violation; paying the wrong party is.
Exposure: FREC discipline against both the sales associate and the broker (reprimand through revocation, administrative fines up to $5,000 per count, restitution and costs), plus civil liability and possible criminal exposure for conversion. Supervision of escrow is a nondelegable broker duty.
3. Ray's phone call about seller concessions: what is the problem and what may an unlicensed assistant actually do?
Read the worked answer
Unlicensed assistants may perform clerical and ministerial work: answer the phone, schedule showings, deliver documents, place pre-approved advertising, compile listings. They may not negotiate or discuss price, terms, or conditions of a transaction, and may not hold themselves out as able to do so.
Ray's statement about seller concessions is terms discussion, i.e., unlicensed activity under Chapter 475 (F.S. 475.42). 'Probably' does not cure it: if the seller refuses, the buyer may claim he relied on a representation made by someone acting for the brokerage, creating misrepresentation exposure. It also exposes the broker for failure to supervise.
The broker should have written procedures limiting unlicensed staff duties, and should document that only licensees discuss terms.