I85PREP
⌘ K
IRA - Attaché d'Administration de l'État study materials
IRA - Attaché d'Administration de l'État study resources

IRA - Attaché d'Administration de l'État practice questions

One question at a time. Build your IRA - Attaché d'Administration de l'État understanding.

First 50 of 190 questions. Each one lists the choices, the correct answer, and an explanation. The checker at the top of this page saves progress in this browser when it is available.

Continue in the practice tool above to load more questions, 50 at a time.

Question 1Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Under Article 20 of the French Constitution of October 4, 1958, which constitutional authority is explicitly tasked with determining and conducting national policy (*détermine et conduit la politique de la Nation*)?

  1. The President of the Republic (*Président de la République*)
  2. The Government (*Gouvernement*) Correct answer.
  3. The National Assembly (*Assemblée nationale*)
  4. The Constitutional Council (*Conseil constitutionnel*)

Explanation

Article 20 of the 1958 French Constitution provides that 'The Government determines and conducts the policy of the Nation' (*Le Gouvernement détermine et conduit la politique de la Nation*). It also provides that the Government has at its disposal the civil administration and the armed forces, and is responsible to Parliament.

Question 2Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What is the primary legal distinction between the scope of statute law (*domaine de la loi*) and regulatory jurisdiction (*domaine du règlement*) under Articles 34 and 37 of the 1958 French Constitution?

  1. Statute law (*la loi*) is restricted to an enumerated list of areas defined in Article 34, while regulatory power (*le règlement*) possesses general residual jurisdiction over all other matters under Article 37 Correct answer.
  2. Regulatory decrees can amend or repeal existing statutes at any time without legislative authorization
  3. Article 34 grants Parliament unlimited legislative competence across all subject matters, while regulations only execute statutes
  4. The Government may enact ordinances under Article 37 without requesting prior parliamentary enabling legislation

Explanation

The 1958 Constitution reversed the traditional Republican supremacy of parliamentary law by establishing a strictly enumerated domain for statutes in Article 34 (*domaine de la loi*). Article 37 establishes that matters other than those falling within the domain of statute law have a regulatory character (*domaine du règlement*), giving the regulatory power autonomous, residual competence.

Question 3Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

In French administrative law, how is administrative deconcentration (*déconcentration*) accurately distinguished from administrative decentralization (*décentralisation*)?

  1. Déconcentration transfers powers from the State to democratically elected local authorities with distinct legal personality, whereas décentralisation appoints state agents to run local councils
  2. Déconcentration delegates decision-making power from central state ministries to local state representatives (*préfets*, field services) within the same legal entity, whereas décentralisation transfers decision-making powers to autonomous territorial authorities (*collectivités territoriales*) having distinct legal personality Correct answer.
  3. Déconcentration is governed entirely by private law, whereas décentralisation remains strictly under public administrative law
  4. Déconcentration eliminates all state hierarchical oversight, whereas décentralisation subjects local authorities to strict prior ministerial approval

Explanation

Administrative deconcentration (*déconcentration*) distributes administrative powers from central ministries in Paris to territorial state representatives (such as the *préfet de département* and *préfet de région*) who remain under direct hierarchical authority of the State. Administrative decentralization (*décentralisation*) transfers administrative competences to distinct legal entities-local authorities (*collectivités territoriales*: communes, départements, régions)-governed by elected assemblies and independent from hierarchical subordination.

Question 4Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What is the primary role of the *Préfet de département* as defined by Article 72 of the Constitution and the Decree of April 29, 2004?

  1. Serving as the elected president of the departmental council (*Conseil départemental*)
  2. Acting as the sole representative of the State in the department, representing the Prime Minister and all ministers, directing deconcentrated state services, and ensuring public order and legality control Correct answer.
  3. Presiding over the judicial tribunal (*Tribunal judiciaire*) and managing public prosecution
  4. Supervising the regional audit chamber (*Chambre régionale des comptes*) and auditing municipal budgets

Explanation

Under Article 72 of the 1958 Constitution and Decree n° 2004-374 of April 29, 2004, the *Préfet de département* represents the State, the Prime Minister, and each of the ministers in the department. The Préfet has charge of national interests, administrative legality control (*contrôle de légalité*), public order, and directs the deconcentrated services of the State (with specific exceptions such as justice, defense, and education).

Question 5Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Which foundational ruling of the Tribunal des conflits established the operational autonomy of French administrative law and founded modern administrative liability independent of the Civil Code?

  1. Arrêt Blanco (1873) Correct answer.
  2. Arrêt Pelletier (1873)
  3. Arrêt Nicolo (1989)
  4. Arrêt Cadot (1889)

Explanation

The *Arrêt Blanco* (Tribunal des conflits, February 8, 1873) is widely recognized as the cornerstone of French administrative law. It established that state liability for damages caused by public service operations cannot be governed by the principles of the Civil Code regulating relations between private individuals, but must follow special autonomous public law rules administered by the administrative courts.

Question 6Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What are the three traditional components of public order (*ordre public*) protected by general administrative police (*police administrative générale*) in France?

  1. Economic growth, price stability, and full employment
  2. Public tranquility (*tranquillité publique*), public safety (*sécurité publique*), and public health (*salubrité publique*) Correct answer.
  3. Administrative efficiency, budget equilibrium, and digital modernization
  4. Religious orthodoxy, ideological uniformity, and civic obedience

Explanation

Under Article L. 2212-2 of the Code général des collectivités territoriales (CGCT) and established administrative jurisprudence, the traditional material components of public order protected by the general administrative police are: public tranquility (*tranquillité publique* - avoiding noise, brawls, riots), public safety (*sécurité publique* - preventing accidents, collapses, disasters), and public health (*salubrité publique* - hygiene, pollution control, epidemic prevention).

Question 7Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What is the standard time limit (*délai de droit commun*) for filing an action for annulment on grounds of ultra vires (*recours pour excès de pouvoir* - REP) before an administrative court in France?

  1. 15 days from official publication or notification
  2. 1 month from official publication or notification
  3. 2 months from official publication or notification Correct answer.
  4. 1 year from official publication or notification

Explanation

Under Article R. 421-1 of the Code de justice administrative (CJA), the standard time limit (*délai de recours contentieux*) to challenge an administrative decision via a *recours pour excès de pouvoir* is two months from the date of its publication (for regulatory acts) or its notification (for individual decisions), provided that information regarding rights of appeal and deadlines was properly indicated.

Question 8Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Which institution has the constitutional prerogative to review the conformity of enacted statutes with the rights and freedoms guaranteed by the Constitution through the *Question prioritaire de constitutionnalité* (QPC)?

  1. The Conseil d'État acting alone as the final judge of constitutionality
  2. The Cour de cassation acting as supreme constitutional tribunal
  3. The Conseil constitutionnel Correct answer.
  4. The Cour de justice de la République

Explanation

Created by the constitutional revision of July 23, 2008, and set forth in Article 61-1 of the Constitution, the *Question prioritaire de constitutionnalité* (QPC) allows any party during court proceedings to claim that a statutory provision infringes rights and freedoms guaranteed by the Constitution. After a filtering process conducted by the Conseil d'État or the Cour de cassation, the referral is decided exclusively by the Conseil constitutionnel.

Question 9Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What is the legal effect of the principle of non-retroactivity of administrative acts (*non-rétroactivité des actes administratifs*) as established in the Conseil d'État's *Société du Journal l'Aurore* ruling (1948)?

  1. Administrative regulations automatically apply to all facts occurring prior to their formal signature
  2. An administrative act can only produce legal effects for the future, starting from the moment it is published or notified, unless authorized by statute Correct answer.
  3. The administration may retroactively withdraw any lawful decision at any time to recover public funds
  4. Courts are prohibited from annulling administrative acts that have already taken effect in the past

Explanation

In its fundamental ruling *Société du Journal l'Aurore* (Conseil d'État, June 25, 1948), the Conseil d'État recognized the non-retroactivity of administrative acts as a General Principle of Law (*Principe Général du Droit* - PGD). An administrative act cannot alter legal situations established prior to its entry into legal force, unless an express legislative provision authorizes retroactivity or the decision satisfies specific corrective requirements (such as regularizing a void decision).

Question 10Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Under the constitutional principle of free administration of local authorities (*libre administration des collectivités territoriales*, Article 72), what is the status of administrative tutelage (*tutelle administrative*) in France?

  1. The Préfet exercises prior hierarchical tutelage, approving municipal council decisions before they take effect
  2. One local authority may exercise supervisory tutelage over another local authority
  3. Administrative tutelage has been abolished; no local authority may exercise authority over another, and state control is purely an a posteriori judicial legality review (*contrôle de légalité*) Correct answer.
  4. The Regional Council exercises budgetary tutelage over all departmental and municipal councils in its territory

Explanation

The decentralization laws of 1982 abolished prior administrative tutelage (*tutelle administrative*). Under Article 72 of the Constitution, local authorities freely administer themselves through elected councils, no local authority may exercise tutelage over another (*interdiction de tutelle d'une collectivité sur une autre*), and state oversight is performed a posteriori by the Préfet through the *contrôle de légalité*, requiring referral to the administrative court (*déféré préfectoral*) to annul an illegal act.

Question 11Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

How does the *référé-liberté* under Article L. 521-2 of the Code de justice administrative (CJA) differ from the *référé-suspension* under Article L. 521-1?

  1. The *référé-liberté* requires a serious and manifestly illegal infringement of a fundamental freedom and obligates the judge to rule within 48 hours, whereas *référé-suspension* requires urgency and serious doubt on legality to freeze an act pending trial on the merits Correct answer.
  2. The *référé-liberté* is reserved exclusively for commercial disputes, while *référé-suspension* handles civil liberties
  3. The *référé-suspension* can be filed without any prior administrative decision, while *référé-liberté* requires an explicit ministerial decree
  4. The *référé-liberté* results in permanent statutory annulment of the challenged administrative act

Explanation

The *référé-liberté* (Art. L. 521-2 CJA) is an emergency procedure where the judge can order all necessary measures within 48 hours if a public authority has caused a serious and manifestly illegal breach of a fundamental freedom (*atteinte grave et manifestement illégale à une liberté fondamentale*). The *référé-suspension* (Art. L. 521-1 CJA) allows the judge to suspend the execution of an administrative decision pending judgment on the merits when justified by urgency and when there is a serious doubt regarding the decision's legality.

Question 12Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

In the jurisprudence of the Conseil d'État, what was established by the *Arrêt Nicolo* of October 20, 1989 regarding the relationship between international treaties and domestic French statutes?

  1. French statutes enacted after an international treaty always prevail over the treaty (*théorie de la loi-écran*)
  2. The Conseil d'État accepted to review the conformity of French domestic statutes with international treaties (*contrôle de conventionnalité*), even when the statute was promulgated after the treaty Correct answer.
  3. The Conseil d'État declared European Community treaties unconstitutional under the 1958 Constitution
  4. International treaties must be formally approved by the Conseil constitutionnel before individuals can cite them in court

Explanation

In *Arrêt Nicolo* (1989), the Conseil d'État reversed its longstanding *Semoules* (1968) doctrine. Applying Article 55 of the Constitution (which gives ratified treaties superior authority over statutes), the administrative judge agreed to set aside a domestic statute that conflicts with an international treaty, including European Community law, regardless of whether the statute was enacted before or after the treaty.

Question 13Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What is the difference between a European Union Regulation (*règlement*) and a Directive (*directive*) under Article 288 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU)?

  1. Regulations are non-binding recommendations, whereas Directives are strictly criminal sanctions
  2. A Regulation has general application, is binding in its entirety, and is directly applicable in all Member States, whereas a Directive is binding as to the result to be achieved upon Member States, leaving national authorities the choice of form and methods Correct answer.
  3. Directives apply directly to citizens without national implementation, whereas Regulations require domestic parliamentary transposing statutes
  4. Regulations only govern external trade, while Directives govern all internal public administration rules

Explanation

Under Article 288 TFEU, a Regulation (*règlement*) has general scope, is binding in its entirety, and directly applies in all Member States as soon as it enters into force without requiring national transposition. A Directive (*directive*) binds Member States as to the result to be achieved, but obligates national authorities to transpose its objectives into national legislation (*transposition*) through appropriate domestic laws or regulations within a set deadline.

Question 14Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Under the French administrative doctrine established in *Arrêt Pelletier* (1873), what determines whether a public official's wrongdoing constitutes a personal fault (*faute personnelle*) or a service fault (*faute de service*)?

  1. Whether the official was in uniform at the time of the offense
  2. Whether the act reveals the human being with their weaknesses, passions, and malice detached from administrative duties (*faute personnelle*), or whether it is tied to the operation and imperfections of the public service (*faute de service*) Correct answer.
  3. Whether the financial damage exceeds 10,000 euros
  4. Whether the official belongs to Category A or Category C of the civil service

Explanation

*Arrêt Pelletier* (Tribunal des conflits, 1873), synthesized by Commissaire du gouvernement Laferrière, established that a *faute de service* is an act inextricably linked to the functioning, errors, or negligence of the administration, engaging administrative court jurisdiction and State liability. A *faute personnelle* reveals the human agent with their malevolence, personal passions, gross unpardonable recklessness, or actions outside the service, engaging personal liability before the judicial courts.

Question 15Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Which principle governs the distribution of competences between regional state representatives (*Préfet de région*) and departmental state representatives (*Préfet de département*) following the territorial administration reforms?

  1. The Préfet de région exercises daily direct command and operational hierarchical tutelage over the Préfet de département in all policing matters
  2. The Préfet de département remains the primary deconcentrated authority for direct public contact, public order, and general state administration, while the Préfet de région steers regional economic development, EU structural funds, and coordinates state policies Correct answer.
  3. The Préfet de département reports directly to the European Commission, bypassing regional authorities
  4. The Préfet de région is an elected local officer, whereas the Préfet de département is a civil servant

Explanation

Under Decree n° 2010-146 of February 16, 2010 modifying Decree n° 2004-374, the *Préfet de région* coordinates state economic and regional planning policies and arbitrates regional budget allocations, while the *Préfet de département* remains the pivotal, primary authority for implementing state policies on the ground, maintaining public order, handling administrative policing, and executing direct legality review over local councils.

Question 16Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What is the legal nature and purpose of the *déféré préfectoral* in French administrative law?

  1. An internal disciplinary procedure used by the Préfet to dismiss municipal police officers
  2. A specific legal action brought by the Préfet before the administrative tribunal to seek the judicial annulment of an illegal act adopted by a local authority Correct answer.
  3. An executive decree immediately dissolving an elected municipal council without judicial review
  4. A binding veto that permits the Préfet to unilaterally annul municipal bylaws without court intervention

Explanation

Under Article L. 2131-6 of the CGCT, the *déféré préfectoral* is the jurisdictional manifestation of the state's legality review (*contrôle de légalité*). Because the Préfet cannot unilaterally annul decisions taken by decentralized local authorities, the Préfet must refer acts deemed contrary to the law to the competent administrative tribunal within two months of transmission to obtain their judicial annulment.

Question 17Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Under the *Loi NOTRe* of August 7, 2015, how was the allocation of competences among French local authorities fundamentally restructured?

  1. The general competence clause (*clause générale de compétence*) was confirmed and expanded for all three levels of local government
  2. The general competence clause was abolished for Régions and Départements, confining them to targeted statutory competencies, while the general competence clause was preserved solely for Communes Correct answer.
  3. All powers of the Communes were transferred unconditionally to the Central State ministries
  4. Départements were transformed into non-voting consultative committees without executive powers

Explanation

The *Loi NOTRe* (Loi portant Nouvelle Organisation Territoriale de la République) of August 7, 2015 abolished the *clause générale de compétence* for regions and departments. Under the reformed framework, only Communes retain the general competence clause to address any local matter of public interest, while Régions focus on economic development, regional transport, and vocational training, and Départements focus on social solidarity and rural development.

Question 18Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

In French public service law, what are the three fundamental principles known as the 'Rolland Laws' (*lois de Rolland*) governing all public services (*services publics*)?

  1. Profitability, privatization, and commercial confidentiality
  2. Continuity (*continuité*), equality (*égalité*), and mutability/adaptability (*mutabilité* or *adaptabilité*) Correct answer.
  3. Decentralization, deconcentration, and delegation
  4. Hierarchy, secrecy, and regulatory immobility

Explanation

Formulated by legal scholar Louis Rolland in the 1930s and recognized as fundamental principles of French administrative law, the three *lois de Rolland* are: Continuity (*continuité du service public* - ensuring uninterrupted public service), Equality (*égalité devant le service public* - equal access and non-discrimination among users), and Mutability or Adaptability (*mutabilité* or *adaptabilité* - allowing the administration to modify service rules to adapt to technological progress and public needs).

Question 19Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What criterion distinguishes an administrative public service (*Service Public Administratif* - SPA) from an industrial and commercial public service (*Service Public Industriel et Commercial* - SPIC) under the *Union des syndicats de commerçants en détail de Nevers* and *Société commerciale de l'Ouest africain (Bac d'Éloka)* jurisprudence?

  1. Whether the service operates in Paris or in the provinces
  2. The three-pronged test examining the service's purpose (*objet du service*), financing sources (*origine des ressources*), and operational methods (*modalités d'organisation et de fonctionnement*) Correct answer.
  3. Whether the service employs more than 100 civil servants
  4. Whether the service operates exclusively online or via physical offices

Explanation

Originating with the *Bac d'Éloka* decision (Tribunal des conflits, 1921) and consolidated in the *Union des syndicats de commerçants de Nevers* and *Société des granits porphyroïdes des Vosges*, the distinction rests on three cumulative criteria: 1) the object of the service (resembling a private commercial enterprise), 2) the origin of resources (financed primarily by user tariffs rather than taxes), and 3) operating methods (using private accounting, management rules, and commercial practices). If these resemble a private business, it is a SPIC governed primarily by private law and judicial courts.

Question 20Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

In the context of the European Union institutional framework, which body represents the heads of state or government of EU Member States and sets the Union's general political directions and priorities without exercising legislative functions?

  1. The Council of the European Union (*Conseil de l'UE*)
  2. The European Council (*Conseil européen*) Correct answer.
  3. The European Commission (*Commission européenne*)
  4. The Council of Europe (*Conseil de l'Europe*)

Explanation

Under Article 15 of the Treaty on European Union (TEU), the European Council (*Conseil européen*) brings together the Heads of State or Government of the Member States, its President, and the President of the Commission. It provides the Union with the necessary impetus for its development and defines general political directions and priorities, but explicitly does not exercise legislative functions.

Question 21Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What is the legal consequence when the *Conseil constitutionnel* declares a statutory provision contrary to the Constitution under a *Question prioritaire de constitutionnalité* (QPC) pursuant to Article 62 of the Constitution?

  1. The provision remains in force, but the judge in the pending case can award financial damages
  2. The provision is repealed (*abrogée*) either from the publication of the decision or from a later date specified by the Conseil constitutionnel Correct answer.
  3. The provision is temporarily suspended for 30 days while Parliament convenes an extraordinary session
  4. The provision is automatically rewritten by the Conseil constitutionnel and forwarded to the Prime Minister

Explanation

Under Article 62, paragraph 2 of the French Constitution, a statutory provision declared unconstitutional through a QPC is repealed (*abrogée*) either immediately upon publication of the Conseil constitutionnel's decision or from a later date determined by the Conseil in its decision, allowing the legislature time to remediate the unconstitutionality without creating a harmful legal void.

Question 22Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Under the jurisprudence of the Conseil d'État in *Commune de Néris-les-Bains* (1902), how is the concurrent authority between general administrative police authorities (*concurrence des polices administratives générales*) resolved between a departmental Préfet and a municipal Mayor?

  1. The Mayor's decision always prevails over prefectural regulations within municipal boundaries
  2. The Mayor cannot enact any police measure once the Préfet has legislated on the same topic
  3. The Mayor may make prefectural police measures more stringent for the commune, but only if justified by particular local circumstances (*circonstances locales particulières*) Correct answer.
  4. The Préfet and the Mayor must sign a joint decree (*arrêté conjoint*) for any local police rule to be valid

Explanation

In *Commune de Néris-les-Bains* (Conseil d'État, April 18, 1902), the Conseil d'État ruled that when a higher police authority (such as the Préfet) has issued a general police regulation, a lower authority (the Mayor) may not relax it, but may aggravate its stringency or add supplementary restrictions within the municipality if particular local circumstances warrant increased protection of public order.

Question 23Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

In the landmark *Association AC !* ruling (Conseil d'État, May 11, 2004), what unprecedented power did the administrative judge introduce regarding the retroactive effect of judicial annulments (*rétroactivité des annulations pour excès de pouvoir*)?

  1. The power to deny judicial review if an annulment would embarrass the central government
  2. The exceptional power to modulate over time the effects of an annulment when retroactive cancellation would cause manifestly excessive consequences for public or private interests Correct answer.
  3. The requirement that all annulled administrative acts must be re-voted by the National Assembly
  4. The authority to convert an ultra vires annulment into a criminal sanction against the public official who signed the act

Explanation

Historically, an annulment for ultra vires operated strictly retroactively, wiping the act out as if it had never existed. In *Association AC !* (2004), the Conseil d'État established that while retroactive annulment remains the general rule, the judge may exceptionally modulate the effects of the annulment over time, delaying its effective date or preserving past consequences if retroactive disappearance would generate manifestly disproportionate harm to the public interest or legal security.

Question 24Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Under the principle of State strict liability without fault (*responsabilité sans faute de l'État*), on what legal basis did the Conseil d'État award damages in the *Couitéas* decision (1923)?

  1. Fault of service (*faute de service*) due to gross administrative negligence
  2. Rupture of equality before public burdens (*rupture de l'égalité devant les charges publiques*) resulting from the lawful refusal of the government to use armed police force to execute a judicial eviction Correct answer.
  3. Direct violation of European Union human rights directives
  4. Contractual liability arising from a public-private partnership

Explanation

In *Couitéas* (Conseil d'État, November 30, 1923), the administration lawfully refused to deploy armed police to enforce a court eviction order because doing so would have provoked armed insurrection. While the refusal was legally justified by public order concerns, the owner suffered abnormal and special damage for the benefit of the community, creating liability based on the rupture of equality before public burdens (*responsabilité sans faute pour rupture de l'égalité devant les charges publiques*).

Question 25Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

In the system of European Union law, what is the role and significance of the preliminary reference procedure (*renvoi préjudiciel*) under Article 267 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU)?

  1. It allows Member State governments to veto draft European directives before publication
  2. It permits or obligates national courts to refer questions concerning the interpretation of EU treaties or the validity of EU acts to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) to ensure uniform interpretation across the Union Correct answer.
  3. It transfers the trial of criminal suspects from national supreme courts to the International Criminal Court
  4. It authorizes the European Parliament to overturn rulings of national constitutional courts

Explanation

Article 267 TFEU establishes the preliminary ruling mechanism (*renvoi préjudiciel*). Any national court may-and courts of last resort against whose decisions there is no judicial remedy (such as the Conseil d'État or Cour de cassation) must-refer questions on the interpretation of EU law or the validity of EU secondary acts to the CJEU in Luxembourg, ensuring that European Union law is interpreted and applied uniformly across all 27 Member States.

Question 26Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What primary statutory characteristic distinguishes Independent Administrative Authorities (*Autorités Administratives Indépendantes* - AAI) such as the CNIL or the Défenseur des droits from standard state administrative bodies?

  1. They are private commercial companies contracted by the government to handle dispute arbitration
  2. They act on behalf of the State without being subject to the hierarchical power (*pouvoir hiérarchique*) or supervisory tutelage of the Prime Minister or any government minister Correct answer.
  3. Their decisions cannot be appealed or subjected to judicial review before any court
  4. They are funded exclusively through voluntary donations from citizens without state budgetary appropriations

Explanation

Independent Administrative Authorities (AAI) and Independent Public Authorities (API), governed generally by Law n° 2017-55 of January 20, 2017, act in the name of the State to regulate sectors touching fundamental rights or economic markets. Their definitive hallmark is their total institutional independence from executive hierarchy: neither the President, the Prime Minister, nor any minister can issue orders, directives, or annul their decisions.

Question 27Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

In French intercommunal cooperation, what distinguishes an *Établissement public de coopération intercommunale à fiscalité propre* (such as a *Métropole* or *Communauté d'agglomération*) from an *Établissement public de coopération intercommunale sans fiscalité propre* (such as a *SIVU* or *SIVOM*)?

  1. EPCIs à fiscalité propre are private non-profit associations, whereas syndicats intercommunaux are state agencies
  2. EPCIs à fiscalité propre are empowered by law to directly vote and levy local direct taxes (such as property taxes or the *cotisation foncière des entreprises*), whereas syndicats intercommunaux are funded purely by member municipal financial contributions Correct answer.
  3. EPCIs à fiscalité propre have no elected council and are administered directly by the Préfet
  4. Syndicats intercommunaux have mandatory police powers, while Métropoles possess only cultural advisory functions

Explanation

Under the Code général des collectivités territoriales (CGCT), EPCIs with own taxation powers (*EPCI à fiscalité propre*: Communautés de communes, Communautés d'agglomération, Communautés urbaines, and Métropoles) have the statutory power to vote and raise direct local taxation (*fiscalité directe locale*). In contrast, EPCIs without own taxation (*syndicats de communes* like SIVU and SIVOM) depend entirely on annual contributions paid from the budgets of their member municipalities.

Question 28Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Under the landmark *Gisti* ruling of June 12, 2020 by the Conseil d'État, what is the current legal criterion determining whether administrative circulars, instructions, guidelines, and soft law documents (*droit souple*) can be challenged via an action for ultra vires (*recours pour excès de pouvoir*)?

  1. Only circulars published in the official journal under the direct signature of the Prime Minister are reviewable
  2. Any document of general scope issued by a public authority can be challenged if it produces notable effects on the rights or situation of individuals or other persons Correct answer.
  3. All administrative circulars are strictly non-justiciable internal operational notes exempt from judicial scrutiny
  4. Only guidelines that impose direct criminal fines on private citizens may be brought before an administrative court

Explanation

In *Gisti* (CE Ass., June 12, 2020), the Conseil d'État unified and modernized its jurisprudence on soft law (*droit souple*). It ruled that documents of general scope issued by a public authority-such as circulars, instructions, recommendations, guidelines, notes, or interpretations-can be challenged via *recours pour excès de pouvoir* when they are liable to produce notable effects on the rights or situation of persons other than the issuing authority (*effets notables sur les droits ou la situation d'autres personnes*).

Question 29Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What is the legal status and binding value of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union within the French legal order following the entry into force of the Treaty of Lisbon in 2009?

  1. It is a non-binding declaration of intent with no legal value before courts
  2. Under Article 6(1) of the Treaty on European Union, it has the same legal value as the EU Treaties and binds French public authorities whenever they implement European Union law Correct answer.
  3. It replaces the French Constitution and automatically nullifies all French legislative acts without judicial review
  4. It applies solely to private employment contracts in multinational companies

Explanation

Article 6, paragraph 1 of the Treaty on European Union (TEU) as amended by the Lisbon Treaty confers on the Charter of Fundamental Rights the same legal value as the primary Treaties (*même valeur juridique que les traités*). In France, it forms part of primary EU law and is binding upon all public administrations and courts whenever they act within the scope of European Union law (*Conseil d'État, Arrêt Mme Gonzalez Gomez*, 2016).

Question 30Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Following the landmark ruling of the Tribunal des conflits in *Bergoend c/ Société ERDF Annecy Léman* (2013), under what strictly narrowed conditions does an administrative action constitute a *voie de fait*, thereby establishing the jurisdiction of the judicial courts (*juge judiciaire*)?

  1. Whenever an administrative official makes an arithmetic error on a tax assessment notice
  2. When the administration, in carrying out a decision, either inflicts a serious injury on a public servant or alters an environmental conservation zone
  3. When the administration executes an act manifestly outside its powers that either causes the total extinction of a property right (*extinction du droit de propriété*) or results in a total deprivation of individual liberty (*atteinte à la liberté individuelle*) under Article 66 of the Constitution Correct answer.
  4. Whenever an administrative decree is annulled for formal procedural defects by the administrative tribunal

Explanation

In *Bergoend* (Tribunal des conflits, June 17, 2013), the Tribunal des conflits fundamentally narrowed the scope of *voie de fait*. An administrative action now only constitutes a *voie de fait* if the administration performs an execution manifestly detached from legal powers that: 1) leads to the total extinction of a property right (*extinction d'un droit de propriété*, rather than simple infringement/restriction), or 2) causes a total deprivation of individual liberty in the constitutional sense of Article 66 (arbitrary arrest or detention).

Question 31Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Which comprehensive legislative code, entered into force on March 1, 2022, brought together and harmonized the general statutory rules governing civil servants across the three branches of the French civil service (FPE, FPT, FPH)?

  1. Code du travail
  2. Code des relations entre le public et l'administration (CRPA)
  3. Code général de la fonction publique (CGFP) Correct answer.
  4. Code de justice administrative (CJA)

Explanation

Created by Ordonnance n° 2021-1574 of November 24, 2021, the *Code général de la fonction publique* (CGFP) entered into force on March 1, 2022. It unified and repealed the four historical foundational statutes of 1983, 1984, and 1986 (known as the *Statut général des fonctionnaires* / Loi Le Pors), creating a single codified framework across the State (FPE), Territorial (FPT), and Hospital (FPH) civil service branches.

Question 32Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

In the hierarchical classification of the French civil service, what functions and recruitment level characterize Category A (*catégorie A*) civil servants such as *Attachés d'administration de l'État*?

  1. Clerical, typing, and direct physical execution duties requiring no academic diploma
  2. Policy design, strategic direction, legal drafting, and executive management functions (*fonctions de conception, de direction et d'encadrement supérieur*), recruited at minimum Bachelor's degree level (Licence / Level 6) Correct answer.
  3. Technical operational execution functions recruited exclusively through vocational certificates (CAP/BEP)
  4. Intermediate application and day-to-day administrative implementation duties recruited with a high school diploma (Baccalauréat)

Explanation

Under the CGFP (Article L. 411-2), civil service positions are distributed into three categories: Category A corresponds to high-level functions of policy design, direction, steering, and executive management (*fonctions de conception et de direction*), requiring a minimum Level 6 qualification (Licence / Bac+3); Category B corresponds to application and supervisory duties (*fonctions d'application*); and Category C corresponds to operational execution duties (*fonctions d'exécution*).

Question 33Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What is the core meaning of the principle of separation of grade and position (*séparation du grade et de l'emploi*) underpinning the French civil service career system (*système de la carrière*)?

  1. A civil servant automatically loses their civil service status and salary whenever their specific job post is eliminated
  2. The civil servant holds their grade (*titulaire de son grade*), conferring permanent status, rank, and progression rights, but is not the owner of their specific operational position (*non-titulaire de son emploi*) Correct answer.
  3. Civil servants can only hold jobs in the private sector while retaining their state office
  4. The administration is legally barred from reassigning or transferring a civil servant to another post within their corps

Explanation

The French career system rests on the foundational principle of *séparation du grade et de l'emploi* (Article L. 411-1 CGFP). The civil servant is titular holder of their grade, which guarantees employment security, career progression through steps (*échelons*) and grades, and salary rights even if their specific post is suppressed or restructured. However, the agent has no subjective property right over a specific post (*l'emploi*), allowing the administration to reassign them according to service needs.

Question 34Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Under Article L. 121-2 of the Code général de la fonction publique and the *Mlle Marteaux* opinion (Conseil d'État, 2000), how does the obligation of secularism and neutrality (*obligation de laïcité et de neutralité*) apply to public agents?

  1. Public agents may freely wear conspicuous religious symbols as long as they do not discuss theology with citizens
  2. Public agents are strictly prohibited from manifesting their religious, philosophical, or political beliefs in the exercise of their public duties, including a strict ban on wearing visible religious insignia Correct answer.
  3. The obligation of neutrality applies exclusively to elected mayors, leaving career civil servants completely unrestricted
  4. Public agents are required to adhere to an official state religious faith designated by executive decree

Explanation

Under Article L. 121-2 of the CGFP and established jurisprudence (*Conseil d'État, Avis Mlle Marteaux*, May 3, 2000), the principle of secularism (*laïcité*) and strict neutrality applies unconditionally to all public agents regardless of whether they have direct contact with the public. A public official is strictly prohibited from manifesting their religious beliefs through dress, symbols, speech, or conduct during service.

Question 35Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What is the legal difference between the duty of professional discretion (*obligation de discrétion professionnelle*) and professional secrecy (*secret professionnel*) under Articles L. 121-6 and L. 121-7 of the CGFP?

  1. Secret professionnel applies only to military officers, while discrétion applies to teachers
  2. Professional secrecy protects specific confidential information designated by criminal statute (such as medical or defense secrets) and is criminally punishable under Article 226-13 of the Penal Code, whereas professional discretion covers all internal administrative facts, documents, and deliberations not subject to statutory secrecy Correct answer.
  3. Discrétion professionnelle allows the public official to sell administrative reports to commercial media
  4. Both duties were abolished by the Open Data directive of the European Union

Explanation

Professional secrecy (*secret professionnel*, Art. L. 121-6 CGFP and Art. 226-13 Penal Code) is a criminally sanctioned duty protecting specific categories of sensitive personal, medical, fiscal, or defense information entrusted to an official. Professional discretion (*discrétion professionnelle*, Art. L. 121-7 CGFP) is an administrative deontological duty forbidding civil servants from revealing internal administrative facts, working drafts, and internal deliberations known through their service, punishable by disciplinary sanctions.

Question 36Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

In the French State civil service, how are the performance and professional competencies of a civil servant evaluated on an annual basis?

  1. Through an informal numerical score (*notation chiffrée*) assigned anonymously without a meeting
  2. Through an annual professional evaluation interview (*entretien professionnel annuel*) conducted by the direct hierarchical superior, resulting in a written report (*compte rendu*) discussing objectives, results, and professional development Correct answer.
  3. Through a mandatory nationwide written examination sat every December
  4. Through a peer review ballot voted on by all trade union delegates

Explanation

Since the generalized reform replacing the obsolete numerical rating system (*notation*), evaluation in the State civil service is governed by the *entretien professionnel annuel* (Decree n° 2010-888 and Articles L. 521-1 to L. 521-5 CGFP). Conducted directly by the agent's immediate line manager (*supérieur hiérarchique direct*), it evaluates the past year's results against set targets, determines future objectives, reviews training needs, and assesses eligibility for grade advancement.

Question 37Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Which of the following describes the statutory administrative position of secondment (*détachement*) under Article L. 513-1 of the CGFP?

  1. The civil servant is dismissed from the civil service with an severance compensation package
  2. The civil servant is placed outside their original corps to perform duties in another public administration or agency, receiving salary from the receiving body while continuing to accrue advancement and pension rights in their original corps Correct answer.
  3. The civil servant is placed on unpaid leave for personal convenience with complete suspension of career advancement
  4. The civil servant performs work for an outside organization while remaining fully paid and assigned to their home ministry

Explanation

Under Article L. 513-1 of the CGFP, *détachement* is a statutory position where a civil servant is placed outside their home corps or administration to serve in another administration, public body, or international organization. The receiving body pays their salary and social charges, but the official continues to benefit in their original corps from rights to advancement and retirement, facilitating interministerial and cross-branch mobility.

Question 38Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Under Article L. 121-10 of the CGFP and the *Langneur* jurisprudence (Conseil d'État, 1944), under what precise cumulative legal conditions is a civil servant required to disobey a hierarchical order?

  1. Whenever the official personally disagrees with the political ideology of the Government
  2. Whenever the order requires working beyond 5:00 PM without prior written notice
  3. When the order is manifestly illegal AND of such a nature as to compromise gravely a public interest (*l'ordre est manifestement illégal et de nature à compromettre gravement un intérêt public*) Correct answer.
  4. Whenever the order involves drafting a financial document without consulting trade union delegates

Explanation

Under Article L. 121-10 CGFP, every public official must comply with instructions from their hierarchical superior, UNLESS the order is manifestly illegal and of such a nature as to compromise gravely a public interest (*sauf dans le cas où l'ordre donné est manifestement illégal et de nature à compromettre gravement un intérêt public*). These two conditions are strictly cumulative: mere illegality alone does not relieve the official of their duty of obedience.

Question 39Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

How does Article L. 121-5 of the CGFP define a conflict of interest (*conflit d'intérêts*) in the French public service?

  1. Any disagreement between two civil servants over vacation scheduling
  2. Any situation of interference between a public interest and public or private interests that is liable to influence or appear to influence the independent, impartial, and objective performance of an official's duties Correct answer.
  3. Any simultaneous membership in two different authorized labor unions
  4. Any budget allocation where municipal spending exceeds regional funding

Explanation

Article L. 121-5 of the CGFP defines a conflict of interest as 'any situation of interference between a public interest and public or private interests which is likely to influence or appear to influence the independent, impartial, and objective exercise of an official's duties'. When faced with such a situation, the official has an affirmative legal duty to inform their hierarchy and abstain from participating in any decision or deliberation touching that interest.

Question 40Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What is the general principle governing concurrent professional activities (*cumul d'activités*) for full-time French civil servants under Article L. 123-1 of the CGFP, and what is the primary exception?

  1. Civil servants may work in any second commercial job without notice or administrative approval
  2. Civil servants must dedicate the entirety of their professional activity to their public tasks; however, they may be authorized to exercise ancillary activities (*activités accessoires*) compatible with their duties upon prior written approval Correct answer.
  3. Concurrent activities are permitted only if the outside employer is a foreign multinational corporation
  4. Civil servants are strictly prohibited from writing books, teaching, or producing works of the mind

Explanation

Under Article L. 123-1 CGFP, civil servants must devote the entirety of their professional activity to the tasks entrusted to them (*principe d'exclusivité*). However, under strictly regulated statutory exceptions (Articles L. 123-2 to L. 123-8), officials may be granted prior authorization by their administration to exercise defined ancillary activities (*activités accessoires*, e.g., teaching, expertise, consultative roles) provided they do not impair service delivery or breach neutrality.

Question 41Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What legal protections are granted to public service whistleblowers (*lanceurs d'alerte*) under the *Loi Waserman* of March 21, 2022 and Article L. 135-1 of the CGFP?

  1. The whistleblower receives an automatic lifetime promotion to the grade of Director General
  2. No public agent may be excluded from recruitment, sanctioned, dismissed, or subjected to discriminatory career measures for having reported in good faith a crime, offense, or serious breach of law Correct answer.
  3. The whistleblower is immune from any liability arising from conduct unrelated to the report
  4. Protection applies only after unrestricted public disclosure, including information protected by national-defense secrecy

Explanation

Law n° 2022-401 of March 21, 2022 (known as the *Loi Waserman*, transposing EU Directive 2019/1937) and Article L. 135-1 CGFP provide extensive protection to whistleblowers who report or disclose in good faith facts constituting a crime, offense, threat, or grave prejudice to the public interest. Retaliatory measures-including dismissal, denial of promotion, transfer, harassment, or adverse disciplinary action-are null and void by law.

Question 42Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

In the remuneration framework of the French State civil service, what are the two distinct structural components of the RIFSEEP indemnitary regime created by Decree n° 2014-513?

  1. A housing grant (*indemnité de résidence*) and a family allowance supplement (*supplément familial de traitement*)
  2. The IFSE (*Indemnité de fonctions, de sujétions et d'expertise*), a monthly allowance based on job responsibilities and expertise, and the CIA (*Complément indemnitaire annuel*), an optional variable annual bonus based on individual professional commitment and performance Correct answer.
  3. A basic industrial hazard bonus and an overtime meal voucher
  4. A single allowance based only on grade and seniority, with no variable component

Explanation

The RIFSEEP (*Régime indemnitaire tenant compte des fonctions, des sujétions, de l'expertise et de l'engagement professionnel*) is the benchmark indemnitary framework for State civil servants. It comprises two complementary pillars: 1) the IFSE, paid monthly based on the classification of the post into function groups reflecting responsibility, complexity, and expertise; and 2) the CIA, an optional annual bonus reflecting individual engagement, dedication, and manner of serving evaluated during the annual review.

Question 43Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Which unified consultative body for collective social dialogue was established by the Law of August 6, 2019 to replace both the *Comités techniques* (CT) and *CHSCT* in the State civil service?

  1. The *Comité Social d'Administration* (CSA) Correct answer.
  2. The *Conseil Supérieur de l'Audiovisuel* (CSA)
  3. The *Commission Administrative Paritaire* (CAP)
  4. The *Conseil de Prud'hommes*

Explanation

Under Article 4 of Law n° 2019-828 of August 6, 2019 on the transformation of the civil service (codified in Articles L. 251-1 et seq. CGFP), the *Comité Social d'Administration* (CSA) was created in the State civil service (and the *Comité Social Territorial* in local government), merging the former *Comités techniques* and *Comités d'hygiène, de sécurité et des conditions de travail* (CHSCT) into a single body for collective dialogue on organization, working conditions, and equality.

Question 44Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

How was the consultative scope of the *Commissions administratives paritaires* (CAP) substantially refocused by the Civil Service Transformation Law of August 6, 2019?

  1. CAPs now determine national foreign diplomacy treaties
  2. CAPs were stripped of systematic prior consultation on collective mobility transfer lists and promotions, and now concentrate exclusively on individual decisions that are unfavorable to agents (e.g. disciplinary actions, refusals of titularization, dismissal for insufficiency) Correct answer.
  3. CAPs now hold sovereign decision-making authority over ministerial budget appropriations
  4. CAPs were permanently abolished across all three branches of the civil service

Explanation

Law n° 2019-828 of August 6, 2019 deeply transformed the role of CAPs (Articles L. 261-1 et seq. CGFP). Prior to the reform, CAPs reviewed all collective mobility movements and promotion rosters (*tableaux d'avancement*). Since January 1, 2020, mobility and promotions are managed through ministerial management guidelines (*Lignes Directrices de Gestion* - LDG), while CAPs intervene only on individual requests or unfavorable decisions affecting careers (sanctions, titularization refusals, license denials).

Question 45Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Under Article L. 532-1 of the CGFP, which of the following disciplinary sanctions belongs to the first group (*premier groupe*), and what is its specific procedural characteristic?

  1. Permanent dismissal (*révocation*), requiring prior approval by the President of the Republic
  2. A reprimand (*blâme*) or warning (*avertissement*), which can be pronounced directly by the administrative authority without mandatory consultation of the disciplinary council (*conseil de discipline*) Correct answer.
  3. Demotion in grade (*rétrogradation*), requiring consultation of the Council of State
  4. Compulsory retirement (*mise à la retraite d'office*), pronounced without notifying the agent

Explanation

Article L. 532-1 CGFP classifies disciplinary sanctions into four groups. Group 1 comprises the *avertissement* (warning, which is not inscribed in the personal file) and the *blâme* (reprimand, inscribed in the file for 3 years). These two light sanctions can be issued directly by the disciplinary authority after giving the agent access to their file, without having to convene the disciplinary council (*conseil de discipline*).

Question 46Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What is the scope and purpose of functional protection (*protection fonctionnelle*) guaranteed to public agents under Articles L. 134-1 to L. 134-12 of the CGFP?

  1. An automated bonus paid when an agent works on weekends
  2. A statutory guarantee obligating the public authority to protect the agent (and their family) against threats, violence, defamation, or insults suffered in the exercise of their duties, and to cover necessary legal defense costs Correct answer.
  3. An exemption from criminal liability when an agent commits intentional crimes outside working hours
  4. A special pension plan granted to senior directors in central ministries

Explanation

Functional protection (*protection fonctionnelle*, Articles L. 134-1 et seq. CGFP) is a fundamental statutory guarantee. The public administration is legally bound to protect public agents and their relatives against attacks, threats, violence, harassment, insults, or defamation incurred because of their official duties. It also covers civil and criminal defense expenses when an agent is prosecuted for acts committed in the line of duty, provided the act did not constitute an inexcusable personal fault.

Question 47Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Under the nationwide framework agreement of July 13, 2021 on telework (*accord-cadre du 13 juillet 2021 relatif au télétravail*), what is the standard weekly ceiling for remote work authorized for a full-time civil servant in France?

  1. 5 days per week, with complete closure of administrative offices
  2. A maximum of 3 days per week (or a quota of days per month/year), to ensure a minimum presence of 2 days on-site and preserve administrative service cohesion Correct answer.
  3. Telework is strictly forbidden for all civil servants under all circumstances
  4. 1 day per calendar month, subject to approval by the Minister of the Interior

Explanation

The inter-branch framework agreement on telework of July 13, 2021 and Decree n° 2016-151 (amended) set the standard telework ceiling at a maximum of 3 days per week for a full-time public agent. This rule ensures that agents maintain at least two days on-site per week to preserve team cohesion, prevent isolation, and guarantee direct public service reception, with exceptions permitted for medical conditions, pregnancy, or exceptional crises.

Question 48Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Under Articles L. 124-4 to L. 124-26 of the CGFP and Article 432-13 of the French Penal Code, what deontological control applies when a senior civil servant departs the administration to work in the private sector (*pantouflage*)?

  1. The official can immediately lead any private company without restriction or oversight
  2. The official must submit their prospective activity to the *Haute Autorité pour la Transparence de la Vie Publique* (HATVP) for prior examination; they are prohibited for 3 years from working for or advising any private enterprise they supervised, audited, or contracted with during the preceding 3 years Correct answer.
  3. The official is sentenced to a mandatory prison term for leaving the public service
  4. The official must forfeit all civil rights and voting privileges for 10 years

Explanation

To prevent unlawful conflict of interest and the criminal offense of unlawful taking of interest upon leaving office (*prise illégale d'intérêts* under Art. 432-13 Penal Code), senior civil servants must notify their administration and the HATVP before taking up private sector roles. For a period of 3 years following the cessation of duties, they are strictly prohibited from working for, holding shares in, or advising any private entity over which they exercised regulatory oversight, supervisory control, or with which they negotiated public contracts.

Question 49Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

What is the statutory nature and duration of the project contract (*contrat de projet*) created in the French civil service by Article L. 332-24 of the CGFP (introduced by the Law of August 6, 2019)?

  1. A permanent contract (*CDI*) that automatically converts into tenured civil servant status after 6 months
  2. A fixed-term contract (*CDD*) concluded for a minimum of 1 year and a maximum of 6 years to carry out a specific administrative mission or project, which terminates upon completion of the project and cannot lead to a permanent contract (*CDI*) Correct answer.
  3. A mandatory temporary contract reserved exclusively for university interns under 25 years old
  4. A lifetime appointment exempt from all civil service performance evaluations

Explanation

The *contrat de projet* (Article L. 332-24 CGFP), inspired by private sector project agreements, allows public employers across all three civil service branches to recruit contractual agents for Category A, B, or C roles to deliver a defined project or operation. The contract is concluded for a fixed period of 1 to 6 years. Crucially, the contract terminates automatically upon completion of the project and cannot be renewed indefinitely or converted into an open-ended contract (*CDI*).

Question 50Role knowledge and relevant French foundations

Under Article L. 114-2 of the CGFP and the landmark *Dehaene* jurisprudence (Conseil d'État, 1950), how is the constitutional right to strike (*droit de grève*) regulated within the French civil service?

  1. Any individual employee can strike spontaneously at any minute without trade union notice or legal restrictions
  2. A strike must be preceded by a 5-day advance notice (*préavis de 5 jours*) filed by representative trade union organizations; revolving strikes (*grèves tournantes*) are prohibited; and the Government can impose minimum service or requisitions to prevent public service paralysis Correct answer.
  3. A strike is lawful whenever a majority of the affected staff vote for it, without advance union notice
  4. The five-day notice may be filed by any individual employee rather than a representative union

Explanation

In *Dehaene* (Conseil d'État, July 7, 1950), the Conseil d'État recognized that the constitutional right to strike (enshrined in the 1946 Preamble) must be balanced against the constitutional principle of continuity of public service. Under Article L. 114-2 CGFP, public sector strikes require a 5-day advance notice (*préavis*) submitted by representative unions stating the reasons, timing, and location. Rolling strikes (*grèves tournantes*) that successively halt services are illegal, and certain security personnel (police, magistrates, prison guards) are legally barred from striking.