Annual Inspection: Water in the Pit, a Failed Ladder, and No Door Restrictor
During a routine annual inspection of a 1988 geared-traction passenger elevator in a six-story office building, you find the following: rated capacity 3,500 lb, rated speed 200 fpm, six stops. The pit contains about 6 inches of standing water, and the sump pump breaker is tripped. The fixed pit ladder's bottom two rungs are rusted through, and the lowest usable rung is about 18 inches above the pit floor. The pit stop switch operates. The car oil buffer is at the low mark on its sight glass. The car door has no door restrictor; with the car stopped 4 feet above the landing, the door can be opened about 6 inches from inside the car. The governor seal is intact, and the car safety was tested last year. The building owner says the elevator runs fine and asks you to leave the operating certificate in place while maintenance catches up.
1. Sort the findings into conditions that must be corrected before the elevator is returned to normal service and items that can be scheduled. Explain the reasoning for each classification.
Read the worked answer
The standing water is an immediate condition, not housekeeping. It corrodes pit equipment, creates a shock hazard at the pit stop switch and buffers, and shows that the pit drainage system is not functioning. The failed ladder is also immediate: the pit must provide a safe means of access and egress, and rusted-through rungs can fail under a mechanic's weight. The low buffer oil level affects energy absorption in a buffer strike; a buffer below its marked level cannot be assumed to perform as designed. The missing door restrictor is a code compliance item because it allows the car door to be opened from inside when the car is not at a landing, creating a fall hazard. These four items should be corrected, with reinspection of the water damage and buffer, before normal service is documented. The governor seal and last year's safety test are not findings; they show the safety test was done. Scheduling is appropriate only for items that do not create an immediate hazard, and nothing in this list qualifies as routine deferral.
2. What should you do about the operating certificate, and what documentation should you leave with the owner?
Read the worked answer
Do not leave the certificate in place as a favor. An annual inspection that finds hazards does not support continued certification. The correct sequence is to record each deficiency with location, measurement, and photograph or sketch, notify the owner in writing, and report the results to the Georgia Elevator Division through the required inspection process. If the local authority or the Division's procedure calls for a red tag or removal from service for imminent hazards, the water, ladder, and door restrictor justify that step. The written report should distinguish code violations from maintenance items and should state what must be verified at reinspection: drained and dry pit, functioning sump pump, replaced or repaired ladder, buffer oil restored to the marked level, and a door restrictor installed and tested. Give the owner a clear list and a reasonable correction timeline, but do not sign or post a certificate until the corrections are complete and verified. If the owner refuses, document the refusal and notify the Division rather than accepting the risk.