The Driver Who Smells of Alcohol
You are an unarmed guard at the vehicle gate of a grocery distribution center. At 05:25, a tractor-trailer driver pulls up. He is scheduled to deliver 22 pallets of frozen food. When he hands you his paperwork, you smell alcohol, his eyes are bloodshot, and his speech is slurred. He says he used mouthwash and “only had two beers last night.” He is 15 minutes from his appointment and says if he is late, he loses a $500 bonus. He becomes loud and takes a step toward you. There is no supervisor at the gate; you have a radio. The driver is not a company employee. Site policy says contract drivers who appear impaired must be denied entry and reported. The driver’s cab is locked; he has the keys in his hand. He has not threatened you. Two other trucks are waiting behind him. The guard shack has a phone and a written incident form.
1. What immediate safety and security actions should you take, and what should you avoid?
Read the worked answer
Treat this as a safety-sensitive impairment issue, not a customer-service problem.
- Keep the gate barrier between you and the driver if possible. Do not stand in front of the truck or reach into the cab.
- Speak calmly and give a clear instruction: “Sir, I need you to park in the hold area to your right and shut off the engine. I am not allowing you through the gate right now.”
- Radio your supervisor and the site safety manager. If the driver attempts to drive through or onto a public road, call 911 and give the truck number, plate, direction, and your observations.
- Do not accuse him of being drunk, argue about the bonus, or discuss his personal life in front of other drivers. Use objective language: “I smell alcohol, your speech is slurred, and your eyes are bloodshot.”
- Avoid physical contact, blocking his body with yours, or trying to take his keys. Those actions can escalate a nonviolent encounter into a fight or a false-imprisonment claim. If he becomes aggressive, create distance and call police.
2. May you search the cab or physically restrain the driver? Explain.
Read the worked answer
Generally, no. You are a private unarmed guard, not a police officer. You do not have authority to search a contractor’s cab merely because you suspect impairment. A search would require consent, a company policy that validly makes search a condition of entry, or police authority. Even then, a forced search of a locked cab is high-risk and should be handled by police or management, not by you at the gate.
Physical restraint is also limited. You may use reasonable force to defend yourself or others from imminent harm, and a private person may arrest in limited circumstances when an offense is committed in your presence or within your immediate knowledge. But the driver has not threatened you, and suspicion of impairment is not itself a crime unless he is driving. Blocking his truck or grabbing him could be false imprisonment or battery. The safer and more defensible action is to deny entry, ask him to park, notify management, and call police if he insists on driving. If he drives, get the plate and direction; do not chase.
3. What should your documentation and notifications include, and what ethical issues arise?
Read the worked answer
Document objectively and promptly:
- Time, driver name, carrier, truck and plate numbers, and the appointment time.
- Specific observations: odor of alcohol, bloodshot eyes, slurred speech, unsteady balance, exact statements such as “only had two beers last night,” and the step toward you.
- Your instructions, his response, whether he parked, whether police were called, and who was notified.
- Names of witnesses, including the drivers behind him, and whether gate video captured the encounter.
Notify the shift supervisor, site safety manager, and the carrier’s dispatcher. Do not send the report to social media or joke about it with coworkers. Ethical issues include fairness-apply the same standard to every driver-and avoiding defamation. Write “appeared impaired” and describe the facts; do not write “was drunk.” Respect confidentiality, but do not let the $500 bonus or the frozen-food schedule pressure you into admitting a potentially impaired driver. The safety of the public road and the warehouse workers outweighs the delivery deadline.