The Verbal Transfer Directive and the New Circuit
You are the AD II acting for a District Director who has been transferred. The Regional Director telephones you with a directive: transfer 14 teachers from three urban basic schools to a newly created rural circuit where a new JHS opened this term with 96 pupils and no trained teachers. Two of the named teachers are preparing candidates for the BECE in eight weeks; one urban school already has a pupil-teacher ratio of 62:1. The SMC chair of that school has written to say the transfers will 'destroy the school'. The District Assembly has not approved the new circuit boundaries, and the circuit supervisor post is vacant. The Regional Director says: 'Do it today; I will inform Headquarters later.' You have no written directive. The teachers' salaries are paid by GES Headquarters, and the district has no transfer budget. The new JHS has no desks, no toilets and no headteacher.
1. What is the lawful basis for transferring staff and creating a circuit? Should you comply immediately?
Read the worked answer
The authority to transfer staff comes from the GES Scheme of Service and delegated administrative instructions, not from a telephone call. Within a district, the District Director or acting officer normally effects transfers; cross-district transfers require the Regional Director; cross-region transfers require Headquarters. A new circuit is an establishment and organisational-structure decision, not a mere deployment: it needs Regional Directorate approval, consultation with the District Assembly, and a defined establishment with a circuit supervisor. A verbal directive is not sufficient for 14 transfers, especially where BECE candidates and a 62:1 ratio are involved. You should not refuse outright - that risks insubordination - but you should acknowledge the directive, request it in writing, and implement a lawful, phased plan. Immediate full compliance could be challenged by the SMC, the union and affected teachers, and could harm BECE candidates. Protect the service by documenting the operational risks and proposing an interim solution: deploy available surplus teachers who are not teaching BECE classes, use the new JHS's allocated posts if any, and request Regional support for the vacant circuit supervisor.
2. Propose a 30-day sequence that addresses the new JHS staffing without breaching procedure or harming BECE candidates.
Read the worked answer
30-day sequence: Week 1 - write to the Regional Director confirming the verbal directive and asking for written approval and establishment details; verify staffing in all 14 JHSs; meet the three urban SMCs; identify teachers who can move without disrupting BECE classes; confirm the new JHS has a headteacher, desks and toilets. Week 2 - submit a phased transfer plan: immediate redeployment of 4-6 surplus or non-examination teachers, with the remainder after BECE; request Regional support for temporary accommodation and sanitation; assign or advertise the circuit supervisor post. Week 3 - consult teachers and unions; issue transfer letters only after written approval; arrange handing-over and replacement. Week 4 - monitor resumption, report to the Regional Directorate, and review pupil-teacher ratios. Do not transfer the two BECE teachers before the examination unless they consent and a qualified replacement is in place. Pair transfers with a school improvement plan for the new JHS.
3. How would you document and communicate the decision to protect yourself and the service?
Read the worked answer
Documentation: keep a file with the date and time of the call, the Regional Director's words, your acknowledgement, the written request for confirmation, and all risk assessments. Send a concise memo to the Regional Director: 'I received your verbal directive on [date] to transfer 14 teachers. To comply lawfully I need written confirmation, the establishment for the new circuit, and clarification of the BECE timetable. I propose the attached phased plan.' Copy the District Director if available and keep HR records. Communicate to SMCs in writing: the district is reviewing staffing; no final transfer until due process. To the teachers: no verbal threats; issue letters only when approved. This protects you from later blame, gives the Regional Director a chance to regularise, and creates an audit trail. If the Regional Director insists on immediate action, ask for the directive in writing and escalate to the Regional HR or legal unit; do not falsify records.