The Inflated Census and the Ghost Teacher
During preparation of the annual school census, you notice that a rural primary school reports 560 pupils. Last year it reported 430; the nearest public school of similar size reports 380. A teacher tip-off says 90 names on the register are former pupils or siblings, and that one teacher on the payroll has not reported for two years. The headteacher is a close ally of the District Director. The school feeding caterer is paid per pupil and has just submitted an invoice for 560 pupils. The next capitation grant tranche of GHS 12,000 is due in three weeks. When you raise the discrepancy, the District Director tells you to 'leave it alone; the numbers help the district get more resources and the MP is watching'. You are the AD II in charge of monitoring and statistics. You have no audit mandate, but you have a copy of the attendance register for one week and the payroll list. The district has a whistleblowing policy but no hotline.
1. What are the issues and your obligations under the GES Code of Conduct and financial regulations?
Read the worked answer
The issues are suspected enrolment inflation, a ghost teacher on payroll, misuse of school feeding funds, and an unlawful instruction from the District Director. Under the GES Code of Conduct and public financial management rules, you must be honest, accurate and impartial; you cannot knowingly certify false data or ignore fraud. The District Director's instruction to 'leave it' is not a lawful defence. You should not alter the census return or the feeding invoice. Your obligations: preserve the register and payroll copies; report through the established channel - Regional Director, Internal Audit, and the whistleblowing policy; if necessary, the Auditor-General or CHRAJ under the Whistleblower Act. Avoid confronting the headteacher alone or disclosing the tip-off. Record the District Director's instruction in a contemporaneous note and ask for it in writing. This is not disloyalty; it protects the service and the District Director from later allegations.
2. Outline a verification plan you can complete in 10 working days without tipping off the headteacher.
Read the worked answer
10-day verification plan: Day 1 - secure the one-week attendance register and payroll list; make copies; log them. Days 2-3 - unannounced school visit with a circuit supervisor; conduct a physical headcount by class, compare with the register and census; photograph the count sheet, not pupils' faces without consent. Day 4 - cross-check the payroll teacher's posting, last pay slip and school records; interview the headteacher and two teachers separately. Day 5 - compare the school feeding invoice with the verified count; check the caterer's daily returns. Days 6-7 - sample 30 names from the register: visit homes or call parents to confirm enrolment; check transfer records. Day 8 - compare with last year's census and nearby schools. Day 9 - prepare a findings memo with evidence and amounts. Day 10 - submit to the Regional Director and Internal Audit; recommend suspension of the feeding invoice and capitation tranche pending verification. Do not tip off the headteacher.
3. How should you handle the District Director's instruction and the risk of retaliation?
Read the worked answer
Handling the District Director: put your concerns in a brief memo, not a verbal argument: 'I have evidence of a 130-pupil discrepancy and a possible ghost teacher. I am required to report. Please confirm in writing if you wish me to delay.' This forces accountability. If the instruction is repeated, escalate to the Regional Director and the Regional Internal Auditor; use the whistleblowing policy and keep a copy at home. Seek advice from the GES legal or HR unit. Protect yourself: do not sign the census return; do not approve the feeding invoice; keep a diary of events; tell only those who need to know. Retaliation risks include transfer, query or isolation. Document any adverse action and report it. The public interest in accurate data and child feeding outweighs loyalty to a colleague. If the District Director is involved, recuse yourself from any decision on the headteacher's discipline and ask for an independent panel.