Two-Day Excursion: Driving Time, Breaks and Reduced Rest
Nikos drives a 12-metre coach for a Patras operator on a two-day excursion to Meteora. He is the only driver on the trip. On Monday he begins at 06:00 after 10 hours' daily rest. His tachograph shows: 2 h 10 min driving, a 15-minute break, 2 h 05 min driving, a 40-minute lunch break, then 1 h 50 min driving. At 17:30, before any further break, the tour leader asks him to add a 45-minute detour to drop the group at a hillside hotel. On the two previous nights Nikos took only 9 hours' daily rest. He is due his weekly rest on Sunday, and the office has not mentioned compensation. On Tuesday the office wants him to start at 05:00 instead of 06:00 to beat traffic. His driver card is valid and the tachograph was calibrated eight months ago.
1. Calculate Nikos's total driving time for Monday if he accepts the detour. Is the detour lawful under Regulation (EC) 561/2006? Explain precisely how the 15-minute and 40-minute breaks count.
Read the worked answer
Driving before the detour: 2 h 10 + 2 h 05 + 1 h 50 = 6 h 05. Adding the 45-minute detour gives 6 h 50. The daily driving limit is 9 hours, extendable to 10 hours on no more than two days in a week, so 6 h 50 is within the limit.
The break rule: after no more than 4.5 hours' driving a driver must take a 45-minute break. That 45 minutes may be replaced by two breaks of at least 15 minutes and at least 30 minutes, taken in that order. The 15-minute break after 2 h 10 is a valid first part. The 40-minute lunch break is at least 30 minutes and comes second, so the pair satisfies the rule and restarts the 4.5-hour clock. After lunch he drives 1 h 50, and the detour adds 45 minutes, giving 2 h 35 since the last qualifying break - well below 4.5 hours. The detour is therefore lawful as regards driving time and breaks, provided the total is recorded and no other limit is breached.
The 40-minute break would not be sufficient on its own: as the second part it must be at least 30 minutes, which it is, but the split rule only works because a 15-minute break preceded it. If the order had been reversed, the 15-minute second part would not count.
2. Assess the daily-rest position: the two 9-hour nights, Monday night's rest if he finishes at about 18:15, and the proposed Tuesday 05:00 start.
Read the worked answer
Regular daily rest is 11 hours. It may be reduced to 9 hours no more than three times between two weekly rests. The two previous 9-hour nights are two reduced daily rests, so Nikos has one reduction left.
If he finishes the detour at about 18:15, the rest until 05:00 Tuesday is 10 h 45. That is less than 11 hours, so it is a third reduced daily rest, not a regular one. It is lawful because it is the third of the three permitted reductions. If he had already used three reductions, the 05:00 start would be unlawful and he would have to start at 06:00 or later so as to take at least 11 hours.
The rest must in any case be completed within the 24-hour period beginning at 06:00 Monday, which it is. He should record the reduced rest and check that he has not exceeded the weekly and fortnightly driving limits. Note that a 10 h 45 rest is not a 'regular' 11-hour rest even though it is longer than 9 hours: any rest between 9 and 11 hours counts as reduced.
3. If the operator reduces the weekly rest to 24 hours, what must be arranged and recorded?
Read the worked answer
A reduced weekly rest of at least 24 hours may be taken, but the 21 hours by which it falls short of the regular 45 hours must be compensated en bloc - in one continuous period - before the end of the third week following the week in which the reduction was taken. The compensation must be attached to another rest period of at least 9 hours; it cannot be split into odd hours.
The operator must schedule and record it, and Nikos must keep tachograph records and any manual entries. The reduced weekly rest and the compensation are checked at roadside inspections, so the office should not simply 'forget' it. If the weekly rest cannot be arranged lawfully, the excursion must be replanned. A 24-hour reduction should not become the normal weekly pattern without the compensation being planned and documented.